Best Italian Restaurants in Starlight, IN

Our server was amazing, the food was fabulous I ate way too much lol. The desert bread pudding was out of this world. Liked the place so much going back two days later!!

Porcini always delivers no matter the occasion. It was a treat to celebrate my mother-in-law’s birthday here, and the food, ambiance, and service were all impeccable. We were lucky enough to sit on the patio to take in the weather and dinner (and dessert :) ) were a lovely accompaniment. The mushroom ravioli and shrimp linguine were two stand out favorites from our meal but everyone loved their dish. Very accommodating of a food allergy at our table as well!

Great experience and delicious and well prepared food. Excellent wine list.

Our meals were delectable and beautiful to see when they came out. Always a 5-star experience at Volare.

We always enjoy going to DiFabio’s when we are in town. Great atmosphere, great service and amazing food. Tonight was no different. The filet was cooked perfectly and the chicken Parmesan melted in your mouth. Throw in the house wine, the lemoncello and they were the icing on the cake. We topped our evening with the flourless chocolate cake. YUM. Highly recommended if you like Italian food.