Best Italian Restaurants in Baldwin

Had an absolutely awesome experience. We loved the food and the ambience and the live music. I ordered the squid ink pasta and my wife ordered the pasta with the shitake mushrooms and truffle sauce. Everything was in good portions and high quality. Expresso martini was mixed perfectly. My wife ordered a mock tail and she said it actually tasted good and wasn't just a cup of juice. Waiter service was awesome. The live music was a great touch also. We will definitely be coming back to try the home made pizza. Highly recommend!

Exceeded expectations! Great food, great vibes, amazing service. 100% date night worthy with a nice dining room and bar area. Highly, highly recommended. Took my wife for Valentine's day dinner. We had a reservation and were immediately seated upon an on time arrival. The place was packed with couples, large groups and singles mingling by the bar. Our server greeted us with within minutes offering to take drink orders and to give us a bread basket. The service the entire night was spectacular! We were checked on by our server and a buser. We started with the martini and lavender lemonade. The martini was a 10/10 with blue cheese olives. The lemonade had a generous amount of purple top shelf gin. No complaints! The food is delicious. Started with the long hot peppers- blistered long Anaheim peppers with crispy crumbled sausage and (what I think was melted shaved parm) with bread crumbs on a bed of smashed spicy tomato and olive oil. It had a nice kick- 10/10 For entrees I had the boneless chicken scarp. What a dish! The sauce is not the typical type you'd get at a catering hall. It was much more flavorful with more depth. The potatoes, crispy sausage, boneless plancha'd chicken were perfect. I even ate my broccoli and carrot. Another 10/10. My wife had the sole. Slightly over done but she enjoyed. I have to say it looked great with the tomatoes and artichoke. We finished with the chocolate mousse with fresh strawberries and cream ... really, really good. The mouse had a slight coffee taste, it hits perfectly. Just a perfect way to end a great meal. The live music and lively crowd really made the vibes amazing. We'll be back and absolutely want to try more.

What a wonderful experience at San Remo for Valentine’s Day. They were so wonderfully accommodating to our family, which included a toddler. The food was excellent, particularly the Chicken San Remo which was tender enough to cut with a fork. Very large portions for a holiday PF. Definitely will come back!

We arrived on time and was seated immediately! The service was on point and when I couldn't decide between 2 dishes the bartender was walking by and I asked her which she would chose!!? She was on point I went with a surf and turf special that was phenomenal! Wasn't rushed at all and dessert was perfect! Love Lenox and Park!! Can't wait to go back!!!

Adam is our favorite waiter. Food is always top notch.