Best Historic Restaurants in Bay Village

This is the second time for us at Estella’s. We loved it so much the first time we brought back the entire family. Our experience was even better the second time around. Food is delicious and the staff is so attentive and sweet! A big shout out to our waiter for the evening, Issman! He was wonderful. Definitely going back again and again!

Valentines Pre-Fixed was absolutely outstanding. The Lobster Cavatelli is worth the price of admission alone. Our Server Jessica was outstanding - attentive, thoughtful, and considerate. My NY Strip was slightly undercooked from my Medium request, but the kitchen was undoubtedly earning their keep on a busy night. Would definitely return, and this is a great spot to celebrate Valentine’s.

Prima is my #1 restaurant in Boston. I’ve been over 6 times in less than a year and it gets better and better each time. My boyfriend and I both tried the filets and they were INCREDIBLE. Truly one of the best steaks I’ve ever had. The Caesar salad and torta gialla are MUST ORDERS if you’ve never tried them!! I’m already thinking of my next reservation!!

We have heard about Contessa for well over a year and finally got there. It was worth the wait. Ride to the 17th floor of the Newbury and enter another world - one of tastefully sumptuous ambience with superb "welcome to Contessa" service and food to die for. The view is amazing, especially from the tables for two along the windows, but make no mistake, this is not a view restaurant. A little pricey, but fair value, and the food is so delicious that we were sorry when each course came to an end. Parking is a challenge (other than an expensive valet option) but in good weather, nearby garages are less than a 10 minute walk. Give it a try! We are sorry we waited so long to get here.

Our servers were wonderful as we had a strict time frame (heading to a show at the Boch Center). They made sure that we received our drinks, appetizers and meals promptly - and never felt rushed. The food was yummy. It was a bit on the pricier side - but spending quality time with my Mom made it worth it. For context - 2 clam chowders, 2 lobster rolls, 2 wines, tax and tip - came in at $180. But I would absolutely head back there again.