Best Restaurants for Special Occasions in Frenchman's Cay

La Tapa was amazing, it truly exceeded our expectations. The food was sublime and the flavors were authentic. The staff were very accommodating to people with allergies also. We had two guests in our group, one with a shellfish allergy and one with a gluten intolerance, but they had many options for both of them that were delicious. Also - the wine pairings!! Trust the staff. La Tapa has prime hospitality and a fun, cultural fusion that is perfect for an evening in St. John!

We had a wonderful experience at Caribbean Fish Market. The food and service were impeccable and the view was amazing. I would highly recommend it.

Probably the best meal we’ve had on our two trips to the island. Beautiful and small venue with outstanding sunset views. The tuna tartar appetizer special was outstanding as was the lobster ceviche which came with some very nicely done root chips. The Chilean sea bass entree was expertly cooked and the filet was nice as well. We opted for dessert and it didn’t disappoint.

As always, Pesce provided wonderful service, cocktails (love Smokey the Pear), and dinner.

Food and service was excellent. They have valet parking which is very convenient given limited places to park in Cruz Bay. The ambiance is amazing with great sunset and bay views. Tables are nicely spaced for quiet conversations. Food was great. I had the Snapper over mushroom rice- excellent. The NY Strip was done perfectly and was tasty. Didn’t do desert but hear good things. Dinner did take 2.5 hours which is good for island time. Never felt rushed and waitress did a great job periodically checking and offering up suggestions Overall a top pick for St John.