Best American Restaurants in Warrensburg

Had a very nice meal on Valentine’s Day. Food was very good as was the service!

Over the past decade, our monthly excursions to various restaurants have cultivated a deep appreciation for the culinary gems that stand out from the mediocre ones. Among these dining experiences, "Beyond the Sea" has emerged as our top choice, claiming the coveted first place in our dining rankings. One dish that truly impressed us was their lobster bisque, which ranks as the second-best we have encountered in ten years. This exquisite bisque is crafted with real lobster and expertly prepared, a refreshing contrast to the canned versions that many establishments often serve. Additionally, the fillet was cooked to absolute perfection, and the Chilean Seabass was equally delightful, showcasing the kitchen's skill in seafood preparation. If you're looking for a memorable dining experience, I wholeheartedly recommend that you make "Beyond the Sea" one of your next restaurant destinations. You won't be disappointed! The Vozzys

We rented the outdoor fire pits for a happy hour family group in January. It was snowing lightly. We dressed in layers and were fortunate the weather was just cold and not windy. The server was super attentive to us, walking through some slippery snow to serve us our drinks. The fire pits overlook the lake, but the snow washed out the view a bit. It was a really “cool” thing to do and we plan on booking the fire pits again next year. I would recommend the fire pits for a happy hour followed by dinner in the hotel.

The experience at Shepard’s at Erlowest was simply amazing! The food was spectacular along with the drinks! Highly recommend eating here! Service was great too! The ambiance was divine!

We discovered this restaurant last year and made a reservation for Thanksgiving dinner. It exceeded our expectations. We were so happy & satisfied with the food, service, price & ambience that we decided to do our holiday dinner there every year. This year we went for Christmas dinner & once again, they met our expectations in every category. Charlie's Bar & kitchen is our new tradition!