Best American Restaurants in Big Pine Key

24 restaurants available nearby

1. La Te Da

4.8

Exceptional(2387)

Price: Expensive

• American • Key West

Booked 13 times today

Tropical open-air fine dining in a casual atmosphere. open seven days a week for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Reservations suggested. Classic elegant cuisine prepared in our unique style, featuring fresh local seafood and the finest cuts of meat. We offer an extensive wine list to satisfy all palates. Come experience a Key West tradition...La Te Da.

A photo of Four Marlins - The Reach Key West restaurant

2. Four Marlins - The Reach Key West

4.5

Awesome(818)

Price: Expensive

• American • Key West

Booked 11 times today

Four Marlins - The Reach Key West is a gem of Caribbean cuisine, nestled in the vibrant neighborhood of Key West. This restaurant stands out for its dedication to fresh, locally sourced ingredients and a truly authentic Caribbean dining experience. Guests rave about their "Tide to Table" dining and the "best Key Lime Pie" they've ever had, highlighting the restaurant’s commitment to regional flavors. The ambiance, paired with oceanfront views, adds to the allure, making every meal feel special. As one diner put it, Four Marlins offers an "amazing experience to celebrate with a jaw-dropping view," ensuring that every visit is memorable and filled with culinary delight.

A photo of Milagro Restaurant and Bar restaurant

3. Milagro Restaurant and Bar

4.8

Exceptional(1012)

Price: Expensive

• American • Key West

Booked 21 times today

Milagro Restaurant and Bar in Key West is a treasure trove of authentic American cuisine, capturing the heart of local flavors with a flair for creativity. Run by the dynamic duo, Executive Chef Kevin Montoya and General Manager Maggie Montoya, this establishment is renowned for its scratch-made approach to traditional American dishes. Specializing in local seafood and wood-grilled steaks and chops, Milagro excels in both quality and taste. Guests rave about the "best swordfish" they've ever had and the "perfectly cooked scallops," making it a must-visit for true culinary delight. The ambiance, combined with a thoughtful selection of wine and craft cocktails, sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. As one diner puts it, it's the "best dinner in five nights!" making Milagro a standout destination in Key West for those seeking the finest in American dining.

4. Ocean Grill & Bar

4.6

Exceptional(1006)

Price: Moderate

• American • Key West

Booked 12 times today

Ocean Grill & Bar in Key West truly encapsulates the essence of Italian cuisine with its innovative seafood-inspired dishes. Celebrated Chef Lea, with over 20 years of culinary experience in Key West, masterfully blends local seafood flavors with traditional Italian techniques, creating standout dishes such as the Shrimp & Grits and the Lobster Benedict. The restaurant has garnered acclaim for its commitment to quality and authenticity, with one reviewer exclaiming, "Seared tuna with avocado was melt-in-your-mouth awesome. Grilled shrimp were super tender in fantastic 4-cheese grits" — a testament to the restaurant's prowess in delivering exceptional Italian fare. Whether you're a local or visiting, Ocean Grill & Bar promises a dining experience that's both authentically Italian and uniquely Key West.

A photo of Latitudes Key West, FL on Sunset Key restaurant

5. Latitudes Key West, FL on Sunset Key

4.8

Exceptional(15355)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Key West

Booked 125 times today

Latitudes in Key West, FL, nestled on the idyllic Sunset Key, is a seafood lover's paradise where the quality and freshness of the dishes consistently impress. Diners rave about the seafood offerings, with one guest celebrating the "delicious" swordfish and "excellent" shrimp Carbonara. The lobster roll, a recurring favorite, is hailed as "always the best," underscoring Latitudes' commitment to excellence. Guests frequently highlight the exceptional service and the breathtaking views that complement their meals, making every dining experience memorable. Latitudes is not just a meal; it’s a culinary journey that captivates all your senses, making it a must-visit destination for authentic and exquisite seafood cuisine.

6. Bagatelle

4.7

Exceptional(4095)

Price: Moderate

• American • Key West

Booked 42 times today

Bagatelle in Key West is a beacon of Caribbean excellence, combining French culinary finesse with the vibrant flavors of the Florida Keys. This gem is renowned for its "outstanding food" and "exceptional service," providing an unforgettable dining experience right in the heart of Duval Street. Diners rave about the fresh seafood and tropical dishes, with one guest applauding the "whole snapper" as "incredible." Another diner highlighted the "glazed bacon" as "the bomb." Bagatelle's dedication to quality is palpable, from the locally sourced ingredients to the southern hospitality that makes every meal a pleasure. It's a must-visit for anyone seeking authentic Caribbean cuisine with a touch of French heritage.

7. A&B Lobster House

4.8

Exceptional(4764)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Key West

Booked 38 times today

A&B Lobster House in Key West is a true gem for those seeking authentic American cuisine with a focus on exquisite seafood and steaks. Celebrated for its fresh Maine and Florida lobster, the restaurant prides itself on a harmonious blend of classic and contemporary culinary styles. Patrons rave about the "best seafood in Key West" and the "phenomenal grouper Oscar," highlighting not only the quality but also the creativity of the dishes. With Certified Prime Angus and Wagyu beef on the menu, every meal is a luxurious experience. Diners consistently praise the attentive service and the stunning waterfront views, making A&B Lobster House a top recommendation for an unforgettable dining experience in Key West.

8. Nine One Five

4.7

Exceptional(4035)

Price: Moderate

• American • Key West

Booked 39 times today

Located in a picturesque Victorian house from 1850, Nine One Five in Key West stands out as a gem of Contemporary American cuisine. Since its inception in 2002, it has not only garnered national and international acclaim but has also been invited twice by the prestigious James Beard Foundation. Patrons rave about its "simple fare prepared properly," highlighting dishes like the "flavorful" Lobster Ravioli and Filet Au Poivre. With glowing reviews like "this was the best meal we had while in Key West!" and an international wine list to enhance the dining experience, Nine One Five offers an authentic taste of Contemporary American delights in a charming setting, making it a must-visit destination.

A photo of Red Shoe Island Bistro restaurant

9. Red Shoe Island Bistro

4.9

Exceptional(1239)

Price: Expensive

• American • Key West

Booked 19 times today

At Red Shoe Island Bistro in the charming heart of Key West, patrons experience the pinnacle of European cuisine with their exceptional beef stroganoff and an array of fresh seafood delights. This quaint bistro, celebrated for its "fabulous food and wonderful service" according to glowing reviews, offers a limited menu that ensures every dish is fresh and flavorful. The expertise in European culinary traditions shines, especially in their acclaimed beef stroganoff made with certified black Angus beef—a dish that keeps guests returning. The ambiance is described as "relaxing, unpretentious, and romantic," perfect for those seeking an authentic European dining experience in a cozy setting. Whether it's the double white linen tablecloths or the vinyl tunes playing in the restroom, every detail at Red Shoe Island Bistro complements the superb dining experience, making it a must-visit destination in Key West.

10. Seven Fish

4.7

Exceptional(3015)

Price: Expensive

• American • Key West

Booked 27 times today

Nestled in the heart of Key West, Seven Fish has become a beacon of American cuisine, offering a sublime dining experience that is both simple and exquisite. Celebrated for its “legendary” food, including the must-try Coconut Thai Curry Snapper, this restaurant guarantees freshness and quality, with locally sourced fish and homemade dishes crafted daily. Patrons rave about the ambiance and the “excellent service,” noting meals like the Banana Chicken and the locals' favorite, 7 Fish Meatloaf, as highlights. Whether it’s your first visit or your fifth, Seven Fish promises an American culinary journey that’s authentic and unforgettable, making it a “great finish to your Key West day.”

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

M
Mike
Atlanta Metro •2 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
Wonderful, wonderful experience. These items were magnificent, the boat ride, crew, Sunset Key, the staff and service, the beach front seating under swaying palm trees, the crystal blue sky and water, the mojito, Crab tostada, sweet and tender Maine Lobster roll and two 'best ever' sweet additions the Salted Caramel Creme Brulee and Key Lime pie. Everything was absolutely on point! However, the two desserts score gold stars as hands down the best we've ever had and best Key Lime Pie anywhere in Key West. This is a must do in Key West! You must have reservations. In the off season with cooler breezes don't let the dress code requests concern you. Don't think - plan it- do it.
More info
Latitudes Key West, FL on Sunset KeyPrice: Very Expensive• Contemporary American• Key West
•
4.8
C
Carol
Wisconsin •2 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
Oh my goodness!! Food and service were top notch!! Definitely would recommend the octopus appetizer and the snapper entree. Delicious!! The risotto was one of the best I’ve had too. Definitely a place to go for a nice relaxing dinner.
More info
Milagro Restaurant and BarPrice: Expensive• American• Key West
•
4.8
J
Jodie
Baltimore / Maryland •6 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
Had an incredible experience at Latada! The service and food were absolutely outstanding, making for a memorable dining experience. The staff were not only professional but also incredibly fun, adding a lively vibe to the evening. The entertainment, especially the 3-sum performance, was amazing and really added a unique touch to the atmosphere. Highly recommend this spot for anyone looking for great food, exceptional service, and unforgettable entertainment!
More info
La Te DaPrice: Expensive• American• Key West
•
4.8
OT
OpenTable Diner
San Francisco Bay Area •2 reviews
5.0
Dined 4 days ago
Beautiful setting and lunch was delicious-could’ve spent the whole afternoon there!
More info
Four Marlins - The Reach Key WestPrice: Expensive• Seafood• Key West
•
4.5
W
Whitneyvip
Chicago / Illinois •2 reviews
5.0
Dined 6 days ago
The food and service were exceptional! Best dining experience of our trip. Highly recommend.
More info
Ocean Grill & BarPrice: Moderate• Seafood• Key West
•
4.6

Explore OpenTable

Big Pine Key

American

Best American Restaurants in Big Pine Key

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

24 restaurants available nearby

1. La Te Da

2. Four Marlins - The Reach Key West

3. Milagro Restaurant and Bar

4. Ocean Grill & Bar

5. Latitudes Key West, FL on Sunset Key

6. Bagatelle

7. A&B Lobster House

8. Nine One Five

9. Red Shoe Island Bistro

10. Seven Fish

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable