Best Neighborhood Gem Restaurants in Islip

Price

$$
$$$
$$$$

Cuisine

AmericanItalianSteakhouseSeafoodFrenchMexican

Regions

Suffolk

Neighborhoods

BabylonBay ShoreBayportBlue PointEast IslipHauppauge

Top Rated

CharmingFancyGood for business mealsGood for groupsGood for special occasionsGreat for brunch

Dining Options

All dining options

Delivery only

Takeout only

Seating Options

BarStandardHigh TopOutdoor

Accessibility

Wheelchair access

18 restaurants available nearby

1. Captain Bill's

4.7

Exceptional(2063)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Bay Shore

Booked 12 times today

Treat those you love to casual, yet elegant waterfront dining on the Great South Bay at Captain Bill's, where you can savor the spectacular sunset over the water while enjoying a fresh daily selection of clams, oysters and fresh local fish along with live Maine lobsters from our lobster tank. We also specialize in premium aged steaks and prime rib, prepared just the way you like it. If you are looking for a lighter bite, join us in our bar where we offer a menu featuring baby lamb chops, shrimp quesadillas and the best burger in town. Wind down the work week on Friday's happy hour with discounted house drinks, domestic beer and wine(Happy Hour Tues-Fri, 4-7). Every Sunday, Captain Bill's presents one of Long Islands premier brunch buffets. Featuring unlimited Bloody Marys, Mimosas and Champagne as well as an extensive buffet. Bring your friends and family for a wonderful Sunday Brunch by the harbor. (Deck and Window tables will be accommodated on a first come first serve basis)

2. View

4.4

Awesome(1927)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Contemporary American • Oakdale

Booked 13 times today

This seaside spot offers the finest fare alongside stunning waterfront views. Our Executive Chef innovates with old favorites, serving up specialties from both land and sea. Dive into this destination and turn an outing from ordinary to extraordinary. - We are open 7 days a week, please contact the restaurant for lunch & dinner hours. - We except reservations for INDOOR dining ONLY.- OUTDOOR dining is on a first come-first serve only, based on availability upon arrival. - Please let us know if you need to cancel or change your plans. - Parties of 8 or more require a $100 deposit. - Maximum of 10 guests per table. - Please confirm your reservations 24 hours in advance.

3. Whalers

4.7

Exceptional(1358)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Contemporary American • Bay Shore

Booked 5 times today

We’re so excited to bring Whalers to Bay Shore and share our love of amazing food and great drinks with the community. Our menu is modern American cuisine, so you’ll find the classics that you’re used to but with our own little spin. In addition to our casual dining and nightlife, we also offer full catering services. With huge windows and views of the Great South Bay, Whalers will be the perfect location to host your next event!We will do our best to accommodate your requests, but we cannot guarantee where you will be seated. Additionally, reservations are unavailable for dockside dining, as outdoor tables are first come first serve.Whalers is modern and fresh with a nod to what it’s like growing up on the Great South Bay. Located right in the middle of the action down on Maple Ave, we are looking forward to getting customers who live locally, but also those who are heading over to Fire Island. We look forward to serving you!

A photo of Marys Pizza & Restaurant restaurant

4. Marys Pizza & Restaurant

4.7

Exceptional(49)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• Italian • East Islip

Come in and enjoy fine dining and real authentic Italian cuisine in a warm atmosphere at our restaurant. Our entrees are served in a welcoming setting that you, your friends, and family are sure to enjoy. Whether you are in the mood to indulge in something new, or want to enjoy some old favorites, we promise that our inventive menu and attentive service will leave you truly satisfied. If you are in a hurry, we have a tremendous take-out service available. Our menu is online so you are able to print it out and reference it at any time. Check out our catering menu and let us deliver your feast for you and your guests to enjoy.

5. The James

4.6

Exceptional(435)

$$$$Price: Very Expensive

• Continental • Babylon

Booked 37 times today

Welcome to The James, an elegant restaurant that boasts two spacious floors, a large bar, and impeccable service.At The James, we have built a menu that you can proudly look upon as your favorite local restaurant, with a design and ambiance that will impress for all special occasions. Our chefs prepare locally sourced seafood, fresh pastas, and USDA Prime-grade steaks from the finest and freshest ingredients. Tantalize your tastebuds with intriguing and fun new dishes.

A photo of Insignia Prime Steak & Sushi restaurant

6. Insignia Prime Steak & Sushi

4.7

Exceptional(6940)

$$$$Price: Very Expensive

• Steakhouse • Smithtown

Booked 68 times today

Insignia Steak & Sushi is the creation of Anthony Scotto - Owner of Blackstone Steakhouse , Rare650 Prime Steak & Sushi, One10 Modern Italian Restaurant, Opus Steakhouse & The Halston American Kitchen and Bar.Like its predecessors, Insignia's inspired menu features the finest prime dry-aged steaks and the freshest Sushi & Seafood, including fresh whole fish, served up in a chic, elegant atmosphere that is also a feast for the eyes. Picture a historic North shore mansion with cedar shakes, quarried stone and a beautiful turret combined with the energy and vibe of a trendy Las Vegas restaurant. "That's Insignia" stated Mr. Scotto, "It's refreshingly unique." Our spacious bar area invites good conversation as well as great times. Relax and unwind. Discuss or celebrate a business deal. Or put the finishing touch on a perfect meal with a cocktail. Exceptional ambiance, cuisine and service. You’ll find them all and more at Insignia.

A photo of Besito Mexican - West Islip restaurant

7. Besito Mexican - West Islip

4.7

Exceptional(1864)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• Mexican • West Islip

Booked 22 times today

Upscale option for Mexican fare and cocktails, with private dining available, and a kids' menu.

8. Karvers Grille

4.7

Exceptional(1819)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• American • Patchogue

Booked 21 times today

We are not just another restaurant, we are your neighbors, your friends, your next-door chefs & your down-the-street bartenders. We believe in a craft approach of the highest-quality ingredients, which is why we work with local farms & partners & our chalkboards always feature specialties items that just came through the door. From our signature flavors & daily eats, to our down-home cocktails & local drafts, we constantly look to provide you with new favorites.

A photo of Chop Shop Bar & Grill restaurant

9. Chop Shop Bar & Grill

4.5

Awesome(916)

$$$$Price: Very Expensive

• American • Smithtown

Booked 7 times today

Located on Main Street in the heart of Smithtown, Chop Shop is one of the newest restaurants to arrive on the North Shore. The restaurant’s interior is accented with brick, hardwood flooring, large retro lamp fixtures, and a unique hand painted mural. Chop Shop is stylishly furnished with a professionally run bar.Chop Shop is the perfect place for casual dining and special occasions, as well as corporate gatherings. Begin your dining experience with a drink selection from our extensive wine list, which offers a variety of great selections, or choose from our exclusive martini menu. Chop Shop’s menu specializes in a variety of sizzling steaks, fresh local seafood, exceptional pasta dishes, seasonal specials and delectable house made desserts.Open for dinner, reservations are accepted for all size parties. Chop Shop also offers a function room, accommodating private gatherings for 6-20 people, available Monday through Sunday.

A photo of Stella Trattoria & Bar restaurant

10. Stella Trattoria & Bar

4.6

Exceptional(1207)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• Italian • Blue Point

Booked 3 times today

Welcome to Stella Trattoria! Join us for some of the very best Italian inspired dishes and cocktails in Blue Point, NY.Whether enjoying the dining room or the bar, you will find a warm comfortable atmosphere free from tension and pressure, a place where friends can meet, relax, spend time and enjoy great Italian food, fun, and entertainment.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

OT
OpenTable Diner
London •1 review
5.0
Dined 4 days ago
Our server Ana was attentive and professional. Thank you for the memorable experience.
More info
The JamesPrice: Very Expensive• Continental• Babylon
•
4.6
M
MaryVIP
New York City •12 reviews
4.0
Dined 4 days ago
Great service, food was just okay… a little disappointing.
More info
ViewPrice: Expensive• Contemporary American• Oakdale
•
4.4
C
CharlesVIP
New York City •63 reviews
5.0
Dined 5 days ago
Delicious food and great service are a staple with this restaurant.
More info
Captain Bill'sPrice: Expensive• Seafood• Bay Shore
•
4.7
OT
OpenTable DinerVIP
New York City •25 reviews
4.0
Dined on Feb 14, 2025
Food was delicious! Service very good!
More info
WhalersPrice: Expensive• Contemporary American• Bay Shore
•
4.7
V
Vicki
New York City •31 reviews
4.0
Dined on Dec 28, 2024
Good neighborhood place. It wasn’t busy when we were there, but it still took quite some time for our food to be served. Didn’t enjoy waiting…but I guess that’s the price of freshly-made food. We will continue to eat there.
More info
Marys Pizza & RestaurantPrice: Moderate• Italian• East Islip
•
4.7

Explore OpenTable

Neighborhood
Neighborhood gem

Islip

Larchmont
Pocantico Hills
West Islip
Sayville
Garden City
Great Neck
Farmingdale
Water Mill
Port Jefferson
Islip
Airmont
Port Chester
Hartsdale
Tarrytown
Jamesport
Croton Falls
New City
Amityville
Smithtown
Shelter Island