What is the best reviewed restaurant in Shelter Island?

The best reviewed restaurant in Shelter Island is The Terrace at the Pridwin

The Best Restaurants in Shelter Island Right Now

Visa Dining Collection

Get exclusive access to primetime reservations at some of the country's hottest restaurants

Book for dinner tonight in New York State

View all

Noah's
4.5
2,226 reviews
Tapas / Small PlatesPrice: ExpensiveGreenport
Booked 5 times today
Vine Street Cafe
4.7
1,844 reviews
AmericanPrice: Very ExpensiveShelter Island
Booked 10 times today
Olive Branch Cafe
4.8
194 reviews
MediterraneanPrice: ExpensiveGreenport
Booked 1 time today
Comomango Mexican Kitchen and Cantina
4.7
58 reviews
MexicanPrice: ExpensiveMadison
Booked 17 times today
Insignia Prime Steak & Sushi
4.7
6,811 reviews
SteakhousePrice: Very ExpensiveSmithtown
Booked 66 times today
Pho Thai - New Haven
5.0
0 reviews
ThaiPrice: ModerateNew Haven
Sophie's Rest.
4.6
50 reviews
AmericanPrice: ModerateSouthold
Booked 4 times today
Muse at the end
4.5
816 reviews
AmericanPrice: ExpensiveMontauk
Booked 2 times today
Red Lobster - Ronkonkoma
4.1
25 reviews
SeafoodPrice: ModerateNesconset
Booked 5 times today
La Fortuna
4.6
235 reviews
ItalianPrice: ModerateStratford
Booked 3 times today
Red Lobster - North Haven
4.1
7 reviews
SeafoodPrice: ModerateNew Haven
Booked 3 times today
Salt + Lime
4.4
114 reviews
MexicanPrice: ModerateWest Hartford
Booked 8 times today
Texas de Brazil - Long Island
4.4
1,184 reviews
SteakhousePrice: ExpensiveNesconset
Booked 20 times today
Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille
4.5
523 reviews
AmericanPrice: ModerateIslip
Booked 13 times today
The Restaurant at Baron's Cove
4.0
61 reviews
AmericanPrice: ExpensiveSag Harbor
Booked 6 times today

Your NYE plans start here

View all

New restaurants to OpenTable in New York State

View all

Outdoor dining in New York State

View all

See what locals rave about in Shelter Island

From verified diners like you

K
Kelly
New York City •4 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
Taylor was a wonderful server and my daughter and her friends had a wonderful celebration! The host and bartender extremely friendly and hospitable. Chill atmosphere with great playlist.
More info
Claudio's Tavern & GrillPrice: Expensive• Seafood• Greenport
•
4
D
Dominic
Philadelphia County •3 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
The view is incredible and the service and food were excellent
More info
The Halyard Restaurant at Sound ViewPrice: Expensive• American• Greenport
•
4.4
L
LauraVIP
New York City •125 reviews
4.0
Dined on Dec 15, 2024
The menu is such fun. You can get small dishes which are ample in size for those with smaller appetites or as a shareable. The sword fish and ribs were excellent ! I wasn’t excited about the salad but the little neck clams were awesome! Great service!!
More info
Noah'sPrice: Expensive• Tapas / Small Plates• Greenport
•
4.5
R
Randall
New York State •1 review
5.0
Dined on Dec 12, 2024
Nice, unhampton, friendly, intimate with good food and service.
More info
Vine Street CafePrice: Very Expensive• American• Shelter Island
•
4.7
S
samVIP
New York City •15 reviews
5.0
Dined on Nov 30, 2024
Delicious food, excellent service, even the music was perfect for the ambiance. Cozy! We had the lamb chops, chicken kabob, Salmon and side of potatoes. Felt like we were eating in someone’s home not a restaurant. Loved it!
More info
Olive Branch CafePrice: Expensive• Mediterranean• Greenport
•
4.8