Orange Restaurants

Table ready as expected. Waitstaff were great. Food and drinks met all expectations. Will frequent often.

The ambiance was lovely - great space! I enjoyed my seafood pie, but I felt there was too much mashed potato in proportion to the amount of seafood in it. The arugula salad was terrific - plenty for two of us - as was the whipped feta with pears. My husband very much liked his meatloaf (it looked like a small portion of the meat to me, but he was fine with it). Our son really liked the scallops as well. There were five, which was generous, but the MP was $55, which is quite high for Brattleboro. We also weren't thrilled when our bill arrived and we found out that the sparkling water was $10, whereas our server only asked if we preferred filtered or sparkling water without mentioning the cost. We will gladly return, but knowing the cost in advance. The menu had some really good choices - the food was yummy and interesting without being dauntingly esoteric.

Our new favorite Christmas Eve tradition! Food was excellent, service was exceptional and the atmosphere was festive.

We had a great time, and the food was amazing. The baked Brie was fantastic! Matt and Jeffery were attentive and personable. We look forward to going back to Johnny’s Tavern!

Another great meal here! Try the calamari - different than the usual fried calamari. The swordfish was perfect! Will be back!