Restaurants near The Olentangy Inn

Our Christmas Eve Dinner was delicious. Sitting in enclosed patio was awesome. Our server was very attentive and friendly.

Our waitress was great! Really made for a great experience

It was a fun holiday dinner with friends from Florida visiting us. There were 8 of us and we hadn’t been together in a long while,so it was fun to visit and catch up. Perfect place with delicious food and ambiance. The waitress gave us ample time to visit before ordering. She was very nice and accommodating. But It was difficult for our waitress as we didn’t sit as couples. Proved challenging when the checks arrived. But no big deal and didn’t interfere with the fun. But I do urge people to look carefully at their check especially when dining with a large group. A lovely dining experience!

Thank you so much for making a special day for our family that much more so. My two kids and I came for dinner to celebrate my wife's, their mom's, birthday. She passed away last year, and what would normally have been a festive and happy occasion was dulled by our loss. The hosts knew that we had come for a birthday dinner and asked if it was mine, but i explained that it was for my wife who had passed. Our server was attentive, friendly, and was quick bring us our drinks. We toasted her birthday and enjoyed a wonderful dinner. The restaurant complimented our desserts and appetizers in honor of her birthday. Thank you so much. It meant the world to us.

This is such a gem in old Worthington. Fantastic food, service and the best Smoked Old Fashion in town. I had the walleye tonight, it was outstanding. Check out the Worthington Tavern next time you’re in the area!