Restaurants near Old St Augustine Village

I found this highly rated restaurant on Yelp. I was unable to find a near future dinner reservation-totally booked. We went there for lunch and had an amazing meal, received very attentive service, and the waiter’s recommendations were spot on. The place has an overall quaint charm. They even have parking which is nearly impossible to find in St Augustine at this time of year. A must try!

We went here for the Miracle Pop-up Bar, one of our holiday annual traditions. The festive drinks are always super fun and delicious, and their food menu is great as ever. Both my husband and I had a couple of their vegan options which were delicious, and the other two with us had the mussels and the chicken sandwich. Portion sizes were so much bigger than I remembered! It’s always busy, especially during the Christmas season so reservations are an absolute must. Even with all the busy-ness, the staff was super prompt, attentive, and friendly. Fun little perk: they gave us special Miracle beanies as a thank you for making a reservation!

The Cordova staff were so nice! I can't say enough nice things about them! Our waiter even purchased me a dessert for my anniversary that I was celebrating! Such an unexpected, nice gesture! The food was absolutely amazing! Melt in your mouth delicious! Lovely atmosphere with low lightening on the beautiful decor including the gorgeous Christmas trees. Soft live piano music topped off the atmosphere. Only confusion was the valet only parking at Casa Monica hotel where Cordova is located. The valet parking is past the Starbucks underneath the hotel. When you turn in it looks like you will drive into a staircase but the valet attendants are there. Highly recommend!!!

Old City House is my favorite restaurant in all of St Augustine. It has that perfect old world ambience. The courtyard is quaint and romantic. The food is absolutely delicious and lavishly decorated. This restaurant also makes the best margarita in town! The wait staff is top shelf. I can’t wait to go back very soon. I highly recommend this hidden gem of our beloved St Augustine 💜

Food was good and servers were really nice but it was clear they were understaffed. They continued to be mice while being visibly frustrated after running out of eggs. The place has nice ambiance and food concept is cool. Hopefully they are able to get more servers and eggs.