Restaurants near Indiana Avenue

Amazing as always! One of the best that Indy has for a dining experience

Service was amazing! Charles was on point with everything.

I have never had anything bad at St Elmo's and tonight was no different. The food and service were absolutely amazing. The waitress was wonderful! I had the ribeye with horseradish gorgonzola butter and it was cooked and seasoned to perfection. The only thing that could be slightly different was the room temp. It was very chilly and cold air kept blowing on us (it was na inside room with no outside door, so I think AC was on). However, it did not detract from the amazingness of the experience tonight.

Ben was amazing. He made our dinner a very pleasing and personal experience. Ben was great with food allergies and took care of us well. Our table was great and holiday decorations looked great. The only negative was it took a bit longer than expected for our entrees to come out, and the restaurant was not crowded. Overall, very good experience and we will come back.

We came to start a new tradition, an annual Christmas dinner with our in laws. It was the perfect place to go through the week, intimate setting and the food is always spectacular.