Restaurants near Buttermilk Creek Park

We love Johnny Manhattans for the food and the atmosphere. Steaks are always terrific and the pork chops are amazing! We love it at Christmas with all the decorations but anytime of year is a great time to dine at Johnny Manhattans!

It was very cold in the restaurant. They did have a fireplace, though, which they seated me right next to. Brighton, the bartender, made me a hot toddy, which he calls the "Baby It's Cold Outside". VERY good. He's a terrific bartender, polished and professional. Dovie, the server, was very attentive and really nice. Too bad there was no piano player sitting at the baby grand. Unfortunately the cheese curds were not that great (they did only have one cook though). The salmon and polenta were fabulous.

Quality and Consistency is an expectation of all Bartolotta and The Commodore checks the box’s for all of those. The setting on Lake Nagawicka is the bow on top. Our daughter’s wedding reception will be there next year and we are so excited to know that every detail will be covered.

Lovely setting overlooking Elkhart Lake. Food and service was good.

Food is always great here. Prices are in the higher range, but the food and beverages compensate!