Best Live Music Restaurants in Carnegie Hill

We had a pre-show dinner and the food was wonderful as always. We gad to wait a bit to be seated for our reservation but still had coffee after dinner and got to our show on time. Good service and nice live piano!

We had a reservation before our tickets so we did the pre dinner theatre menu! The service was astounding and the menu choices had something for everyone at one table. The pumpkin bread rolls were fantastic. I loved the apple and endive salad. My friends had the squash and ricotta. It was a cold dish so that was a little confusing. It felt as if that should have be served warm. Probably would have made it more enjoyable. The steak, fish and gnocchi were 10/10. The service was 5 stars, very attentive and made sure to get us out on time. I would definitely recommend.

Perfect chicken, delicious sides, drinks were fabulous, and we enjoyed the music on Friday night which set a lively mood but we could still hear each other talk. Our server was so pleasant too. Definitely recommend to anyone, wish we could visit more frequently!

Lovely afternoon tea in a fabulous hotel - we loved it! Annie, our waitress, was absolutely lovely, warm and friendly and went above and beyond to make sure we had everything we needed. The two ladies who greeted us on arrival for the afternoon tea were less friendly and welcoming. Lovely food though - well done Whitby!

Ambiance: great/ food: starters,great/ main: steak: tough,not high quality. Cocktails: not good, why can’t restaurants in NY make a simple, descent vodka martini, a real man’s do, not “dirty “ and all that crap. Sorry!