Best Neighborhood Gem Restaurants in St. Peters

Once again, we had a great time and great meal at Charlie Gitto’s “On the Hill.” Our server, Scott, did a great job (as well as all of the other helpers of the wait staff). Our food was delicious as always and my Valentine’s Day Special - “Land and Sea” was good to the last bite. Our visits to Charlie Gitto’s is never complete without the Cannoli. We look forward to coming back again soon!

Everyone was very nice and cheerful. Food delicious as always. Menu varied and new specials.

Perfection! We had a reservation and were seated immediately, our wonderful server, Jill appeared within seconds to greet us and take our drink orders. Our food was delicious and she continued to take excellent care of us. The manager checked in on us and the evening was just perfect.

My boyfriend and I came here for Valentine’s Day dinner. We had a reservation at 6:30 but didn’t get sat until about 7:00. I was okay with that though because they had ample waiting seating and I could tell it was very busy. We ordered the calamari appetizer to start. The flavor was great, but the sauce made the breading soggy and the breading was falling off. We both agreed that we would have preferred the sauce on the side to dip in so that the breading would stay crispy. I got the petite filet and the baked potato, both were delicious! The steak was cooked perfectly and the flavor was great. The baked potato was sizable. I also had the Wild berry Lemonade cocktail and it was GREAT! One of the best cocktails I’ve ever had. Overall it was a great experience!

My husband and I have been to multiple nice steakhouses in the area, and this one has been our favorite thus far. The service was friendly and quick, and the steak was cooked to perfection. Perfect for a date night or special occasion, but the menu had a decent amount of less expensive options as well. Will definitely be returning in the future.