Best Historic Restaurants in Kildeer

Server Michelle was pleasant and helpful when mixup in kitchen occurred

This was our first time at O'Toole's. We both really enjoyed the menu selections and agreed that we'd go back. I may have missed it, but it would have been nice to know they had dedicated parking around the back. We were able to find parking, but knowing would have helped. Food was delicious and the service was attentive!

Celebrating our wedding anniversary here was a great decision. Lucia's warm and welcoming nature made it even more special. The staff was very attentive and made sure we had everything we needed. The food was incredible, and the ambiance added to the charm. We can't wait to return!

My first experience at a tea service and it was awesome. Gerri's place was so neatly decorated i really didn't know what to expect. Our server was very sweet and accommodating and the food, yes super small portions, was delicious. My wife explained that this isn't a "regular " restaurant in terms of quantity of food but it's an experience. And an experience it was!

This is our favorite spot for a number of reasons. Namely the staff and the service. Sure the food is great. Cocktails are wonderful. But the staff in the star of the show. Always welcoming. Always courteous. They really are what makes the experience at Mickey Finns great each and every time. In my humble opinion no other bar/restaurant in Libertyville hold a candle to Mickey Finns in this regard. Thank you. Appreciate you. See you around the way soon.