Best Restaurants for Special Occasions in West Indy

We go to St. Elmo’s every year for our family Christmas dinner. St. Elmo’s was amazing, yet again! The food was delicious and we loved our server, Glen!! He made the experience so much more enjoyable with his friendly demeanor. Thank you, Glen! We will see you again soon!

We had reservations for a table for a birthday party for my wife. There were five of us. Our server promptly asked for drink orders, and we placed an order for two appetizers. The cheese bread and the toasted ravioli were both great. I ordered the halibut special, and it was outstanding. Two others ordered veal parmesan and chicken parmesan, they also said they were delicious Our nine year old ordered spaghetti, and was happy with that. We enjoyed the atmosphere and again, the service was outstanding.

The food was out of this world and very fairly priced considering the quality you're being served. The decor is gorgeous and being next to Gainbridge is always amazing. The drinks were perfectly made. What was most impressive is the level of knowledge carried by our incredibly courteous server, Shay. She knew so much not only about the menu but also the food, itself. Cunningham Group did it again with this diamond in the rough of the downtown chain restaurants. We shared the Hamachi Crudo and the Prime Rib and the other has the dry aged new your strip and the Chillean sea bass. We also started with the beef carpaccio and got the French onion Mac and cheese and broccolini. We finished with a couple of espresso martinis and then the chocolate cake and the chocolate tart and those were equally out of this world. In an area with so many restaurants that don't surpass the average mark, Commission Row surpassed out expectations, ten fold! Thank you Shay and the rest of the team at CR

From the time we walked in until we left we had the treatment of special guest. We went to celebrate a special occasion just for us. The service was amazing and the food was perfection all the way around. The app lobster voodoo is perfect, we had ribeye and classic filet and I have to say it is tied with Hells Kitchen in Vegas as the best steak I have ever had. The Lobster mac n Cheese is a perfect side. Our dessert was the chocolate sin cake and the name says it all. Over all our experience was a 10 out of 10 and we will definitely be back.

Our meal was a family celebration and everything was perfect. We appreciated the seating arrangements. The food was exceptional. Our server was friendly, attentive, and met every request we had.