Best Restaurants with a Fireplace in Atlantic Highlands

I grew up right across the bridge from the Molly Pitcher. We never could imagine dining at this famous place. Today, after many decades, I had the great good fortune to brunch here with an old friend. I have to say, I was not prepared for the quality of the entire experience. From welcoming ambiance, to drop- dead view to luscious food and impeccable service, it was more than I could have hoped for. San Francisco eateries have nothing on the MPI! I will absolutely dine here every time I am back this way.

All we can say is that everything about this quaint pub is it is amazing. Something out of a hallmark channel (lol) loved the ambiance- we will be back - the food is amazing especially the pizza - the best is watching the specialty drinks being made - bartenders and staff are all friendly - feels like home. Friendly warm atmosphere- keep it going 💕

Fantastic food, especially the New Year’s specials like cheesy pull apart bread and lobster ravioli. Service was a little slow. Food was quick to be delivered to our table - entrees came out before we were done with appetizers - but was delivered by runners rather than our server so we had to sit with empty glasses till our server finally returned. Probably a staffing issue due to the New Year’s holiday.

We really enjoyed the Seven Fishes dinner on Christmas Eve. Our waiter Anthony was great. It was a great value.

Another great experience at the Drifthouse—food, surroundings, and view are wonderful. However, the consistent attentive, professional, and very friendly staff are always reasons to return frequently. The manager, Hafid Elbroji, always makes us feel welcome and at home. Thank you!