Best Restaurants for Foodies in Lumberville

A beautiful delicious experience. Like being in Italy.

We had a great waitress named Nicole who not only took great care of the orders, food, and drinks- but also helped us by making paper numbers for our white elephant holiday gift exchange! She went the extra mile, was professional and personable.

Eclectic vibe and food. The layout is quaint and cozy, service was above average and staff was very attentive. The only downside was the actual seating smallish cafe style, great for casual eating but lacking for a dining experience. Overall the food and vibe were well worth the trip. I will definitely head back in the spring when they reopen.

Obsessed and need to come back! We went during December and it was beautifully decorated and looked so cozy and inviting. Went for brunch and the food/drinks were incredible. Will definitely be back!

I've always enjoyed The Inn at Barley Sheaf but hadn't been here in quite some time. With the holidays upon us, and a new Executive Chef, Greg Vassos, it was time to go again. And I'm glad to have been there. The atmosphere is always inviting, the service (Kyle was our primary waiter) was impeccable, and the food was excellent. Our party of three sat at a table with a direct view of the kitchen, which was fun to watch, and took advantage of the Chef's Tasting Menu which consisted of: Kombu Cured Hamachi Crudo, Pork Belly, Beef Tartare, Wild Harvested Scallops, Jurgielwicz Duck Breast, and a Whipped Matcha Cheesecake for desert. The only miss, for an otherwise excellent meal, was that the scallops were forgotten. When desert came out, and we asked about the scallops, the staff were very quick to apologize, offered to bring them then, offered to package them for take-home, and offered to reduce our bill. As the rest of the meal was so good, and we knew we'd be back, we asked for the credit as a gift card to be used for our next wonderful meal there. Of the aforementioned plates we sampled, the duck was spectacular, the beef tartare was good but could have had more beef versus potato. Overall, an excellent dining experience ... once again.