Best Restaurants with Private Rooms in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

Fantastic food from start to finish. Definitely get the flank steak if you like heavily seasoned and super flavorful steak. The Ribeye was good as well, but the Flank Steak felt like a signature dish.

Consistently good with amiable servers. Prompt service and lovely ambiance.

We had a lovely new years brunch (though I do wish they actually served brunch fare). Everything was very delicious! The service, while very friendly and accommodating, got a little slow toward the end as it got busier, which is understandable. It would’ve been okay except we were in a booth that was one of two they have for parties of six but maybe six short, slim people? Pretty uncomfortable, especially in that corner spot, I spent the whole meal with my arms up over the back of the booth. I’m chubby but the rest of my party were regular sized men and one slim woman and we all felt squashed. But otherwise, a beautiful meal on a lovely day.

We had a reservation which helped. We were seated outside and it turned out to he ok with the heat lamps Oddly they were out of a some drinks - no sprite, could not make a Paloma. But waiter helped us out and comped a drink to ease the disappointment. Food was great. Beer great as always. Waiter excellent and friendly despite it being so busy.

Greytone is nothing short of exceptional! From the moment you engage with their team, you’re met with professionalism, creativity, and unmatched attention to detail. Sara the manager went above and beyond to deliver top-notch quality, ensuring every aspect of the experience exceeds expectations. The dedication and passion they bring to their work truly set them apart. If you’re looking for excellence and innovation, Greytone is the gold standard. Highly recommend!