Best Date Night Restaurants in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

Had to place our entire order at once — server wouldn’t take drink order first, so around 45 minutes into the reservation, wine finally came out. Went on a Tuesday and the noise level was insane. Could hardly hear my dinner date unless nearly shouting. Acoustics of the space are just awful. Food was pretty good, though, garlic bread was like a savory cinnamon roll, pizza was decent. Not sure I’d return though, given the experience itself.

Amazing celebration after our wedding. The food is always great and our server, Jessie was cheerful, appreciative of our celebration, brought a mud pie as a wedding cake and genuinely joined in to make our experience so festive and joyful! The bay was beautiful with clear blue skies. It could not have been better. Thank you for helping us celebrate the day.

Everything was exceptional here! Attentive service, great choices of food and drinks, and a warm and inviting atmosphere. We ordered way too much food because we wanted to try everything.

Everything about the food was excellent including the oysters, the lobster bisque, the Caesar salad and especially the fish and chips. Our drinks were well made and worth the money. The view is amazing and the service is great. Don't miss this experience when you are in San Diego.

I am beyond satisfied with my experience. I had been waiting for a year for the chance to have this experience. So when I randomly caught an open reservation I had to take it. The food was amazing, the beef short rib was amazingly tender. I was honestly drawn to the ambience and was blown away. The snow falling at the top of the hour was a great addition. We walked the venue and took lots of pictures as well.