Best Date Night Restaurants in Shelter Island
Price
- $30 and under
- $31 to $50
- $50 and over
Cuisine
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility
4 restaurants available nearby
How is content generated
See what locals rave about
- VVictoriaNew York City •1 review5.0Dined todayWe had a 7:00 p.m. reservation and was promptly seated. Our waitress was very friendly but not overdoing it. Our food came out promptly and perfect The Braciole and spicy meatballs are our go-to for appetizers and we both had a filet mignon cooked perfectly . Both me and my husband went home with leftovers because there was so much food. We go every year for our anniversary. And will continue coming back. Price is great for great food. Only complaint was multiple people going in in sweat outfits I wish they would look at the dress code a little more strictly for a high-end restaurant.More infoCast Iron Chef Chop House & Oyster BarPrice: Expensive• Steakhouse• New Haven•4.6
- KKellyNew York City •4 reviews5.0Dined 1 day agoTaylor was a wonderful server and my daughter and her friends had a wonderful celebration! The host and bartender extremely friendly and hospitable. Chill atmosphere with great playlist.More infoClaudio's Tavern & GrillPrice: Expensive• Seafood• Greenport•4
- JJohnNew York City •9 reviews5.0Dined 4 days agoAs usual Artisan does not disappoint. It is consistently wonderful. Thank you.More infoArtisanPrice: Expensive• Contemporary American• Southport•4.7
- AAndrewSan Francisco Bay Area •14 reviews5.0Dined 6 days agoWe celebrated our anniversary and had a delightful meal. Our server, Paige, was excellent. Just the right balance of attentiveness and friendliness, while not rushing us. The food was excellent. The view of the water made everything perfect for a special occasion.More infoFresh SaltPrice: Expensive• Seafood• Old Saybrook•4.6
- OTOpenTable DinerNew York State •1 review4.0Dined on Nov 29, 2024Wonderful food, attentive service, but very noisy. Cries out for a carpet or any sound abatement that might allow conversation at a table for 2 to4. Miss the old original Gurney’s corny Italian rococo decor that was a relief from the now ubiquitous “ zen”running to “ Amish “ look of un inviting plain colorless Uber simple gray fixtures. Looks as if it was decorated by Monks who have taken a vow of poverty. Art work is all black, gray and during late fall no view of gorgeous ocean after early sunset. No music either but the noise would drown it out anyway. Very pricey for teensy portions.More infoScarpetta BeachPrice: Very Expensive• Italian• Montauk•4.4
Discover best date night restaurants in Shelter Island
Embark on a romantic culinary journey in Shelter Island, Suffolk, where the dining scene masterfully blends serene views with a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for a date night. Shelter Island offers a selection of restaurants that cater to an array of tastes, ensuring that every couple finds the perfect spot to complement their evening. From intimate settings with cozy fireplaces to picturesque patios overlooking the water, these eateries prioritize creating a memorable dining experience. Guests can expect a range of dishes crafted from local and seasonal ingredients, highlighting the area's rich culinary heritage. Each restaurant on Shelter Island strives to provide not only exceptional food and service but also an atmosphere that enhances special moments, making them ideal for a romantic outing. Whether it's your first date or a cherished anniversary, these establishments make every occasion feel unique and personal, promising an unforgettable night out.