Best Cozy Restaurants in Saint Augustine Beach

We have been here 3 times in the last week and a half so that should tell you how good it is. The service and food are both amazing. We’ve been for early lunch on Sunday and late lunches twice. Everything we’ve ordered has been so delicious and the cookies from the marketplace are amazing as well! This will be a weekly lunch for us and look forward to bringing friends here.

Everything was perfect—from the service, to the ambience, the cocktails, and the food. This was our first time trying their food, and I could not have been more pleased. It was fresh, quick, and delicious. Highly recommend. One of my new favorites in St. Augustine.

I recently celebrated my 70th birthday with my wife at the Old City House restaurant and we had an indubitably delicious dinner with our fantastic waitress serving us. She sat us at a lovely corner table for two next to a window. The ambience was cozy, warm, elegant, relaxing, romantic and simply superb! The service was absolutely fantastic and the food was amazing, delightful and scrumptious. We enjoyed a very nice bottle of Ken Wright Cellars Pinot Noir 2023 from Williamette Valley, Oregon before we ordered our dishes. According to my wife, her magnificent lamb dish was wonderful! I savored a lovely cup of she-crab bisque and the beef tenderloin, which was a very flavorful, juicy, moist, succulent and tender Filet Mignon served with Vegetables, Gratin Potatoes and Topped with Herb and Truffle Butter. Dessert was quite delectable! We had an amazing dining experience. I told our fantastic waitress," ¡No me gusta, me encanta!"

What a great experience and meal. The sorbet palate cleanser before the main course and that bread were really wonderful touches. We will be back and thank you for the birthday dessert!

Great restaurant in the middle of the historic district of St. Augustine. Loved the old house feel. Server was always available until the end of our meal when we needed to leave for an event. We had to bypass coffee as it was taking 30 minutes for dessert and coffee. The staff was exceptional. The meal cooked and served excellently. The ambiance might have been better with a different table. We were seated in a small room in back by the black curtain where staff continued to go back and forth. I would suggest when you make a reservation to see if you can get into the main dining area.