Best Authentic Restaurants in Water Mill

Calissa in the Hamptons is an absolute must-visit! From the moment we arrived, the ambiance was warm, inviting, and full of energy. The service was top-notch—attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable about the menu. The food? Outstanding! I had the ossobuco special, and it was melt-in-your-mouth perfection—rich, flavorful, and cooked to absolute tenderness. She had the salmon, which was beautifully prepared, fresh, and seasoned to perfection. And let me tell you, the lemon potatoes were to die for—perfectly crisp on the outside, soft and buttery inside, with just the right amount of citrusy zest. The cocktails were well-crafted, the wine list was impressive, and the whole experience felt like a true Mediterranean escape. Whether you're looking for an intimate dinner or a lively night out, Calissa delivers on all fronts.

Service and atmosphere were wonderful! Food was incredible as usual. Had two dips, a salad, saganaki (perfection!), zucchini chips (excellent!), and delicious branzino and potatoes. A fantastic evening, we will be back.

Wonderful food, wonderful drinks, wonderful service. It was Valentine’s Day, and there were several tables with a lot of young children. So it was unusually loud for the first half hour or so. That was a bit annoying. Once they left, the vibe definitely improved. Overall, though, I really love this place.

R'AIRE Is a rare find in the Hamptons. Delicious, quality, locally sourced food and a varied menu served in a calm, understated setting. Our favorite!!!!

We will miss Boa until they return in May! Have a good winter!