Best Steakhouses in Port Jefferson

Wow—this place is rare in the best way possible! The steak? Absolute perfection. The tuna? Melt-in-your-mouth incredible. The calamari? Crispy, tender, and packed with flavor. And the asparagus? So good it could turn a carnivore green! No wonder this is the restaurant owner’s favorite spot—if great steak is the measure of success, this place is well done. Our waiter, with over six years under his belt, wasn’t just knowledgeable—he was like a walking, talking Michelin guide. Highly recommend for an unforgettable meal! 🔥🥩🍷

The food and staff are top notch and consistent! A boys night favorite spot! A+++++

amazing steak and sushi. I drove 45 minutes to come back to Insignia after i moved further west from Smithtown. don't miss it.

Our server was absolutely outstanding, courteous, knowledgeable, polite. Perfect night to go on a date night. It was quiet, relaxing food as always was spectacular.

Benoit, Giovanni, and the rest of the team at Rothmann's are incredible. It's the little things that they do right that make the rest of the experience truly exceptional. My wife and I went there to celebrate our 13th wedding anniversary (24 years together) and the food was exceptional but the service is what sets Rothmann's apart. This is our new favorite steakhouse and will come here to celebrate special occasions and milestones.