Best Steakhouses in Plainview

The staff is pleasant and the ambiance inviting. The chairs are odd for a restaurant of this caliber (I understand that the room I was seated in may be different in some seasons but in the winter I don’t expect to sit on a lawn chair). The price fix was reasonable. Steaks were good. Bread was excellent. The waiters remembered to make a birthday wish with candle and song. Whiskey is very expensive. Caesar salad dressing tasted bottled. The manager, Cliff, was attentive and really cares to see the dining experience is maintained. Overall, a nice evening out.

Another fabulous evening at Rothmann’s. There’s a reason we keep coming back, the ambiance, the warm welcome, the service, the amazing food…it all makes it worthwhile. As soon as you walk in you are welcomed by Jon and Benoit. You need to visit master mixologist, Alejandro at the bar for a perfect drink before your dinner. Now I may be biased but after years of coming to Rothmann’s we do have our favorites, food and staff members. We always request to be seated with Keith and Giovanni. They will make your evening a memorable one. Don’t forget to order the seafood platter, a must for seafood lovers. The filet mignon is always cooked to perfection. Don’t forget to finish your meal with an affogato, you won’t regret it.

Friendly hostesses. Bartender was great. Cocktails were yummy. Food was delicious, and our steaks were cooked perfectly. I really have to say that the best part of our night and dining experience was our waiter Jesse. What a gem he is. He went over the different cuts of meat and how they were differed. He gave us suggestions. He was so delightful, friendly, fun and professional. He also helped me out with wine choices. When I go back I’ll request his section. Perfect date night out.

This is an update to a previous post where I gave a zero rating. I had the opportunity to dine here once again. Since my last dining experience, they hired a new General Manager to correct the issues they were having. While the food before was sub par there certainly has been a marked improvement and is excellent. The terrible service we had prior was a completed turn around. Juan and Lin treated us if we were family and royalty. Their attention not only to us but every other diner around us was impeccable. The new General Manager Joey came to the table several times making sure both the food and service was up to Scotto’s standards. My previous rating of zero is now a 5. Joey, Juan and Lin made sure our dining experience was top notch and an enjoyable evening both by the service and food. I will definetly go back.

Came for my wife’s Birthday and the place was Beautiful oh my goodness I mean perfect haven’t seen a restaurant this nice in a long time , the waitress and waiter were on point and made us hungry when he went over the menu . However I have to go back my steak was great but wish my veggies were a little more tasteful the Mash potatoes were really good but I must go back to Try something different