Best Steak Restaurants in West Caldwell

Had a fantastic Valentine’s Day at The Highlawn! The drinks were on point, the food was super tasty, and the whole place had this great romantic vibe with amazing décor. It was the perfect spot for a date night. We’re definitely going back again soon. I highly recommend it if you’re looking to make the day extra special!

Ambiance is beautiful. All of the servers and staff were extremely attentive. The food and cocktails were great! Only thing i wish was that the meat came to the tables a little more frequently. We waited a while for certain meats. But the meat itself was seasoned very well & delicious. The Tres Leche cake for dessert was AMAZING! Will definitely be coming back.

I thoroughly enjoyed the diverse food options and the reasonable prices. However, I was disappointed with the second-floor dining room. It was extremely cold, almost like an unventilated attic. I would definitely return if they could accommodate me on the first floor. 5-Stars if you’re not dining on the second floor when it’s below 40 degrees outside.

Very good especially on a busy day like Valentine’s Day and even though it was a prefix menu. It had plenty to choose from. Definitely will be coming back and recommending it to friends and family.

It was very slow when I had lunch here. Staff was very attentive. Food portion were also great. We kept it simple and ordered the skirt sticks, fried calamari as our apps & penne vodka with chicken for our entree. Had leftovers (goes to show the portions can be GREAT). Would definitely come again!