Best Sicilian Restaurants in West Sayville

The food and the service was spectacular. I will definitely be returning and will bring people to this restaurant because of the pleasant and welcoming staff and the delicious food.

I had a great experience at Butera’s. They were great with changing my reservation last minute and being flexible for accommodations. The food came out super quick and staff was readily available to help. This might be one of the best meals I have had out dinning.

Piccola Cucina never disappoints. Personnel is kind and attentive, the food is outstanding and the noise is decent. My go-to place when I crave Italian food! Burrata is always fresh and there are so many pastas that you can go several times in a row without eating the same thing. Alfio is the sweetest and kindest host, but everyone is really great.

Dinner was wonderful, mostly because our waitstaff Elideth was able to make the perfect wine and food recommendations. Our table was in the middle of what is a small space, so it felt crowded. But the delicious meal and wonderful service made up for that.

Food was outstanding. It’s family style so you get really big portions. Service was great and management is very attentive. I highly suggest going there if you are in the area.