Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York State

Best Sicilian Restaurants in West Sayville

Price
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility

5 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Butera's Restaurant of Sayville restaurant
4.6
Exceptional(1427)
Price: Moderate
• Sicilian • Sayville
Booked 11 times today
Butera's Restaurant of Sayville is a cornerstone in the American dining scene, celebrated for its exceptional cuisine and the unique family-style dining experience it offers. Nestled in the heart of Sayville, this restaurant prides itself on serving up dishes that are both heartwarming and exquisite. Patrons rave about the "fabulous dining experience" and the "consistently good" quality of the food. Signature American dishes like chicken parm and burgers are given an Italian twist, making Butera's a culinary standout. The ambiance is described as "terrific" and the staff as "very friendly," creating an inviting atmosphere that complements the delicious meals. Whether it's for a casual lunch or a special occasion, Butera's promises a memorable dining experience with every visit.
A photo of Stella Trattoria & Bar restaurant
4.8
Exceptional(1168)
Price: Moderate
• Sicilian • Blue Point
Booked 12 times today
Welcome to Stella Trattoria! Join us for some of the very best Italian inspired dishes and cocktails in Blue Point, NY.Whether enjoying the dining room or the bar, you will find a warm comfortable atmosphere free from tension and pressure, a place where friends can meet, relax, spend time and enjoy great Italian food, fun, and entertainment.
A photo of Marys Pizza & Restaurant restaurant
4.7
Exceptional(48)
Price: Moderate
• Sicilian • East Islip
At Marys Pizza & Restaurant, nestled in the heart of East Islip and Islip Terrace, diners indulge in a symphony of authentic Italian flavors that resonate with every bite. Celebrated for its "best pizza around" and acclaimed "best vodka sauce in the game," Marys offers a culinary journey that transcends the ordinary. Guests rave about the "unbelievably excellent" chicken hero and the lasagna that makes you say "OMG!" The commitment to authenticity and quality is palpable, as one diner highlighted, "Whether it's pizza or pasta dishes; whatever your tummy desires, it's fresh, well prepared and delicious!" With its charming atmosphere and consistently lauded service, Marys Pizza & Restaurant is a beacon of Italian culinary excellence in Suffolk County.
A photo of Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore restaurant
4.5
Awesome(970)
Price: Moderate
• Sicilian • Bay Shore
Booked 9 times today
Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore is a beacon of American cuisine in Bay Shore, renowned for its commitment to quality and authenticity. This spot dazzles diners with its rustic yet modern American offerings, creatively prepared with locally sourced ingredients. Patrons rave about their culinary experience, highlighting dishes like the "out of this world" pork chop and the "always delicious" double cut pork chop, which have become fan favorites. The atmosphere is equally praised, with live music and an industrial chic decor that adds an extra layer of delight. Reviewers consistently mention the "excellent service" and the warm welcome from staff, making Butera's a must-visit for a truly memorable American dining experience.
A photo of Mamma Lombardi's restaurant
4.5
Awesome(530)
Price: Moderate
• Sicilian • Holbrook
Booked 24 times today
Mamma Lombardi's is a family-owned traditional Italian restaurant. The Lombardi family has been actively serving food in Long Island for over 40 years. This little eatery has built its reputation on incredible Neapolitan recipes and a totally scratch kitchen. Mamma Lombardi's is a natural fit for large groups, as family dining is such a staple of Italian culture. The restaurant even has several private event spaces where diners can celebrate any occasion.Mamma Lombardi's menu is divided between lunch, dinner and the pizzeria. Pizza is such a versatile dish in the hands of the Mamma Lombardi's kitchen staff that it got its own menu with dozens of recipes as well as having a build-your-own option. The main dinner menu contains all of the classic Italian dishes diners could want: spaghetti carbonara, grilled filet mignon, chicken parmesan, chicken bolognese, penne with shrimp and veal milanese just to name a few.
‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
  • Wesley
    Columbus •4 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 1 day ago
    My wife and I always travel for Christmas and we love Italian dining. We do our best to find the most authentic, charming places we can. Typically these are going to be the places that seat 50 people and you may not think about going in. We’ve ate at multiple spots in Chicago, Indianapolis, Atlanta, Columbus, Cincinnati, Charleston, Alexandria… this is our new favorite! My goodness is was amazing! The staff was on top of it and soooo friendly. Our waiter, Gabriel was extraordinary! We legit felt like we were in Sicily. If you make one reservation in New York, make it here.
    More info
    Piccola Cucina EstiatorioPrice: Moderate• Italian• SoHo
    4.7
  • HeidiVIP
    Orange County •15 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 1 day ago
    this has to be the best Italian food we have had and we have been all over Italy even the couple next to us mentioned how good it was and better than Italy so yes we recommend but be prepared. It is tight quarters very very tiny restaurant but well worth it and I will come here every time I come to New York thank you for the great service and the great food we’re still talking about it
    More info
    Piccola Cucina Osteria - Spring St.Price: Expensive• Italian• SoHo
    4.7
  • Anthony
    New York City •20 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 2 days ago
    Great food and value nice place , only drawbacks parking lots especially on weekends. Worth the parking hassle. Very nice in nice weather they open large doors.
    More info
    Butera's Restaurant of Bay ShorePrice: Moderate• Italian• Bay Shore
    4.5
  • Rachna
    California Central Coast •11 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 6 days ago
    This is my go to place whenever I am in town. The ambience is warm, cozy and charming. The food is amazing and the service is excellent, always. The manager, who is incredibly knowledgeable about wines, makes each diner feel welcome and at home. This special touch is a rarity in New York! Make a reservation days in advance, walk-ins impossible. I’ve tried.
    More info
    Piccola Cucina UptownPrice: Moderate• Italian• Upper East Side
    4.8
  • Rich
    New York State •1 review
    5.0
    Dined 7 days ago
    Another great dining experience at Buteras's. The food was great and service was excellent. We have never had a bad experience here. 5 stars!
    More info
    Butera's Restaurant of SayvillePrice: Moderate• Italian• Sayville
    4.6
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2024 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo