Best Sicilian Restaurants in Theater District

50 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC restaurant

1. Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC

4.6

Exceptional(29779)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Theater District

Booked 355 times today

Carmine's on 44th Street in NYC's Theater District embodies the essence of Southern Italian cuisine, offering a dining experience akin to an Italian American wedding feast. Guests rave about the "abundant portions" and "authentic flavors," highlighting dishes like the "best chicken Parm ever" and "fantastic lasagna." Known for its family-style servings, Carmine's creates a convivial atmosphere where "every meal feels like a Sunday afternoon at Grandma's." Reviewers consistently praise the "amazing atmosphere" and "excellent service," making it a must-visit for both locals and tourists seeking a traditional yet exceptional Italian meal in the heart of Times Square.

A photo of Piccola Cucina Uptown restaurant

2. Piccola Cucina Uptown

4.8

Exceptional(2146)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Upper East Side

Booked 80 times today

Piccola Cucina Uptown, nestled in the vibrant Upper East Side of New York, offers a delightful escape to the heart of Sicily with its authentic cuisine. As praised by diners, it's a place where "the food was amazing" and where traditional Sicilian dishes like "pasta alla bottarga" and "branzino cooked in bread" shine. Chef Philip Guardione brings Sicilian flavors to life with creativity and flair, ensuring each dish is a testament to Sicilian culinary traditions. The atmosphere is consistently lauded as "cozy" and "welcoming," making every visit memorable. Whether it's the "homemade pistachio gelato" or the "freshly cooked lasagna," every bite at Piccola Cucina Uptown transports diners straight to Sicily, making it a must-visit for authentic Sicilian cuisine in New York City.

3. Il Melograno

4.8

Exceptional(1290)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Hell's Kitchen

Booked 16 times today

Il Melograno in Hell's Kitchen is a treasure trove of authentic Italian cuisine, right in the heart of New York City. Celebrated for bringing the essence of Sicily to the bustling streets of Manhattan, this charming restaurant is lauded for its "extraordinary experience" with "pure and divine" Sicilian fare, as one diner raves. From handcrafted pastas to meticulously prepared dishes that taste of "genuine love and care," every meal at Il Melograno promises a taste of Italian grandmother's kitchen. Guests consistently praise the "amazing homemade pastas" and the warm, inviting atmosphere, making it a must-visit for both locals and tourists seeking an authentic Italian meal.

A photo of Piccola Cucina Estiatorio restaurant

4. Piccola Cucina Estiatorio

4.7

Exceptional(1635)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • SoHo

Booked 89 times today

Piccola Cucina Estiatorio, nestled in the vibrant SoHo neighborhood of New York City, is a gem for lovers of authentic Mediterranean cuisine, with a special focus on Sicilian and Greek dishes. Diners rave about the "authentic, delicious Italian cuisine" and the "best tiramisu and cannolis." The atmosphere is described as "cozy" and "charming," providing a delightful backdrop to every meal. Frequent guests highlight the consistent quality, saying it's the "best Italian restaurant in NYC" and praise its "amazing food and service." Whether it's the "stunning experience all around" or the "best grilled calamari ever had," Piccola Cucina Estiatorio stands out as a must-visit for an authentic Mediterranean dining experience right in the heart of the city.

A photo of Piccola Cucina Osteria - Spring St. restaurant

5. Piccola Cucina Osteria - Spring St.

4.7

Exceptional(2484)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • SoHo

Booked 45 times today

Nestled in the vibrant heart of SoHo, New York, Piccola Cucina Osteria - Spring St. is a treasure trove of authentic Mediterranean cuisine, specifically showcasing the rich flavors of Sicily. Since its opening in 2013 by Chef and owner Philip Guardione, it has become a beloved spot for food enthusiasts seeking the true taste of Italy. Patrons rave about its "amazing" food and "authentic ambiance," with dishes that transport you straight to Sicily. The restaurant is renowned for its cozy and welcoming atmosphere, coupled with service that makes diners feel like family. Reviewers consistently highlight the unforgettable culinary experiences, such as the "mind-blowingly delicious" Sicilian sardine pasta and the table-side tiramisu that brought tears to a diner's eyes. Piccola Cucina Osteria is not just a meal; it's a journey through the heart of Mediterranean culinary tradition, right in SoHo.

6. Sicily

4.4

Awesome(542)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • Hell's Kitchen

Booked 66 times today

Located on Restaurant Row in the heart of Manhattan in the Hell’s Kitchen neighborhood and Theater District, Sicily Osteria is a dining destination that appeals to local residents and office workers, as well as Broadway theatergoers. The restaurant offers several dining experiences, from its more formal main dining room that exudes a rustic elegance enhanced by vintage green walls, exposed brick, custom tiled floor and white tablecloths. It's front dining room features an expansive bar, perfect for casual dining; plus, several bistro-style tables; and in the far back, a spacious, naturally lit, enclosed patio garden and atrium transports guests to a lush garden oasis.

A photo of Chazz Palminteri Italian Restaurant restaurant

7. Chazz Palminteri Italian Restaurant

4.8

Exceptional(2660)

Price: Very Expensive

• Sicilian • Theater District

Booked 24 times today

Chazz Palminteri Italian Restaurant, nestled in the vibrant Theater District of New York, is a haven for seafood lovers seeking authenticity and excellence. The restaurant dazzles with standout dishes like Zuppa di Cozze and a pistachio crusted Halibut that guests rave about, describing it as "perfectly cooked" with an "excellent crust." Patrons consistently praise the fresh, high-quality seafood, with reviews highlighting the "blue point oyster as the best in town" and the calamari and scallops in pasta with a "great tangy taste." The commitment to quality is evident, as one diner noted, "The food is classic southern Italian, but at a high quality." Chazz Palminteri’s offers an unforgettable dining experience where every seafood dish promises a delightful burst of traditional Italian flavors.

A photo of Bocca Di Bacco (Theatre District - 45th St.) restaurant

8. Bocca Di Bacco (Theatre District - 45th St.)

4.4

Awesome(3355)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Theater District

Booked 16 times today

Located in the heart of New York's Theater District, Bocca Di Bacco is a celebrated gem for authentic Sicilian cuisine. This chic establishment is praised for transforming a historic space into a modern culinary haven, serving a dynamic menu that highlights the flavors of Sicily. Patrons rave about the "spectacular" arancini and the "divine" homemade pasta, which is a testament to their commitment to freshness, as part of their farm-to-table philosophy. Reviews frequently highlight the restaurant's dedication to quality and service, with one diner noting, "The food was SO good...homemade and yummy" and another exclaiming, "The octopus was amazing and the pasta just like I needed." This spot is not only a must-visit for its delightful dishes but also for its excellent service and the enchanting dining experience it offers right next to the city's famed theaters.

9. Osteria Nonnino

4.6

Exceptional(234)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • West Village

Booked 74 times today

Nestled in the vibrant West Village of New York, Osteria Nonnino offers a stellar dining experience with its contemporary Italian cuisine that blends the culinary traditions of northern and southern Italy. Chef Tony Kavaja, along with his wife Vita Russo, crafts authentic Italian dishes that resonate with diners. The rave reviews highlight dishes like the "fabulous" Orecchiette Con Bufala and the table-side Cacio e Pepe, emphasizing freshness and authenticity. Guests are especially fond of the "delicious and perfectly prepared" entrees and desserts, like the tiramisu made fresh at your table, which one diner described as "life-changing!" The restaurant's cozy atmosphere and attentive service make it a neighborhood gem, where every meal feels like a special occasion. This blend of excellent food, immersive ambiance, and warm hospitality ensures Osteria Nonnino is not just a meal, but a memorable experience, making it a must-visit for lovers of refined Italian cuisine.

A photo of The Leopard at des Artistes restaurant

10. The Leopard at des Artistes

4.6

Exceptional(3263)

Price: Very Expensive

• Sicilian • Upper West Side

Booked 37 times today

Located in the New York landmarked Hotel Des Artistes, and surrounded by the astonishing 1920s murals by Howard Chandler Christy, THE LEOPARD at des Artistes cuisine respect the rich Italian cultural traditions, the absolute quality of ingredients, and the balance between dishes based on rural elements, such as pasta, vegetables, cheese, and seafood ingredients from the Mediterranean. We look forward to welcoming you to our home, in one of the most iconic spaces in New York City, Hotel des Artistes. Buon appetito!

How is content generated

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

G
Gabby
Baton Rouge / Lafayette •1 review
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
Small restaurant with amazing atmosphere. I lived in Rome for a period so my standards for Italian food are pretty high. THIS MET THAT LEVEL. The food was authentic and so was the service. The owner (I'm assuming) greeted each party with a "Ciao!" The food was top notch too. We got the Arancini Catanesi to start. Felt like I was back in Trastevere. The atmosphere was warm and inviting and noise level was energetic but not hectic. Would definitely come back during the spring/summer to sit out on the balcony.
More info
Piccola Cucina UptownPrice: Moderate• Italian• Upper East Side
•
4.8
T
TonyVIP
New York City •22 reviews
5.0
Dined 4 days ago
If you're searching for one of the most delicious and AUTHENTIC Italian restaurants in the city, look no further. Recipes that will remind you of nonna, with beautiful ambiance, great service, and great value. One of the neighborhood gems in Hell's Kitchen.
More info
Il MelogranoPrice: Moderate• Italian• Hell's Kitchen
•
4.8
L
Leigh
New York City •2 reviews
5.0
Dined 7 days ago
The food is always great. Service is very professional. Highly recommend. A very nice neighborhood restaurant.
More info
Bocca Di Bacco (Theatre District - 45th St.)Price: Moderate• Italian• Theater District
•
4.4

Discover best Sicilian restaurants in Theater District

Immerse yourself in the vibrant Sicilian culinary scene right in the heart of Manhattan's Theater District. Our curated selection of restaurants offers a delightful exploration of Sicilian gastronomy, renowned for its rich flavors and traditional cooking techniques. Each establishment showcases a commitment to authenticity, featuring menus packed with dishes that highlight the unique ingredients and recipes of Sicily. Whether you're craving the robust taste of freshly prepared cannoli or the intricate layers of a well-crafted caponata, these restaurants promise an unforgettable dining experience. The Theater District is not only a hub for Broadway entertainment but also a melting pot of exceptional dining options, where the essence of Sicilian cuisine comes to life. These restaurants are celebrated for their atmospheric charm and exceptional service, providing an ideal backdrop for both casual and sophisticated dining. Dive into the heart of Sicily without leaving New York City, and enjoy a culinary journey that combines the allure of Italian cooking with the dynamic energy of one of the city's most iconic neighborhoods.

Explore OpenTable

Theater District

Sicilian

Best Sicilian Restaurants in Theater District

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Award-winning

Accessibility

50 restaurants available nearby

1. Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC

2. Piccola Cucina Uptown

3. Il Melograno

4. Piccola Cucina Estiatorio

5. Piccola Cucina Osteria - Spring St.

6. Sicily

7. Chazz Palminteri Italian Restaurant

8. Bocca Di Bacco (Theatre District - 45th St.)

9. Osteria Nonnino

10. The Leopard at des Artistes

See what locals rave about

Discover best Sicilian restaurants in Theater District

Explore OpenTable