Best Seafood Restaurants in Dexter

The food and customer service at Mitchell’s Fish market was excellent. You are checked on in a timely manner, and the manager came and spoke to us during Christmas and thanked us for coming. The restaurant is very beautiful and there is even a section where you can look at the fresh fish. I will definitely go here again when it’s not the holidays, but I definitely had a great experience on Christmas. 

This was my first time at the Gandy Dancer and I was impressed. It was Christmas Day and the restaurant was crowded. The staff was wonderful and gave us excellent service. Despite the crowd we never felt neglected. To begin, I ordered the butternut squash soup and my husband had the chowder. For the main course I had the scallops with risotto and my husband had the prime rib. Both meals were excellent and were good portions. The creme brulee for dessert was a perfect ending to a great meal. I thought that the prix fix price was reasonable too. Add all this to the ambiance of the old railroad station and it was a wonderful way to spend Christmas. We will definitely go back.

The food was amazing!, service outstanding we were served by Amanda, ambience perfect, love that place and 💯 will recommend and for sure will go back soon

Good service, ambiance, food…. We got two whole lobsters, one steamed one broiled. Streamed one over-steamed. Stick to broiled. Steak and seafood pasta excellent. Will be back

Everything was A1 from the time we arrived until we left. Adam was FANTASTIC!!! His sense of humor, his professionalism, his friendly demeanor provided the best service I’ve received out of all the times I’ve dined. What I did find that was disappointing, is how casual the dress code is. There was a time we would dress up to come dine. However I was noticing guests wearing jogging suits and gym shoes. It just changes the entire ambience.