Best Seafood Restaurants in Carnegie Hill

Amazing food exceptional service and the ambiance so beautiful

Amazing experience. It was my first time and I had such a great time. Though busy, the ambience felt warm and inviting. It felt like being home with family. Our server Elona was a bit cold and stand offish but all others who touched the table - Kesha and Ciro were an absolute pleasure. Also a thank you to Erik. The food was delicious and plentiful, we had the seafood and squid ink pasta, the calamari. Also the Italian cheesecake and tiramisu were to die for. Would return.

Very fresh seafood and all dishes were served with good taste profiles

We love Kellari Taverna. We always eat here when we come to New York. The food is delicious and they are always aware of your plans so that you can get to the theater on time. The service was excellent, and the ambiance is wonderful. If you have not tried it as yet, you must.

Our experience was excellent. We arrived early but were seated right away. Service was excellent. I had the Rib Eye and my wife had the Fillet. They were cooked to perfection and excellent cuts of meat. We had asparagus and mushrooms as sides. Both portions were large and nicely prepared. We skipped desert and opted just for coffee. It was our first time at Ocean Prime and we were very happy.