Best Pizzerias in Pennington Villas

Spectacular food, great service, and the perfect setting for a romantic Valentine’s dinner! The black truffle sausage rigatoni was absolutely INCREDIBLE and loved the NA options for drinks as well. A little bit on the pricier side but well worth it for a special occasion! We will be back!

My husband and I went for Valentine’s Day and it was a great experience. We loved the prefixed menu and will definitely be back! Everything we ordered was so good. We especially loved the Chicken Parm, Spicy Vodka Rigatoni, and the broccolini!

Always a treat - truly a hidden gem in Nashville. Went for Valentine’s Day and we split a bottle of wine, the pork sausage pizza, and the lasagna special. The lasagna wasn’t my favorite, but the pizza was divine and we also got the delicious carrots as an appetizer. Will be back again and again.

The Zia fries were AMAZING! The Angel pie was equally amazing and delicious!

I’m a big fan of Emmy Squared, especially the Colony pizza. The combo of the crust with the crispy pepperoni, pickled jalapeños, and honey drizzle makes for a savory, sweet flavor. There are menu options for salads, sandwiches, burgers, and wings. I’ve yet to hear anyone complain about the menu or quality of the food. What could use some focus is the attention to detail with service. If someone orders wings, make sure they have enough napkins. If someone orders a pizza, make sure there are enough utensils at the table after the appetizers are cleared. The East Nashville location wasn’t particularly busy during our visit, but the wait staff wasn’t particularly focused on more than the basics. We had lags between requests and returns to the table. (And it’s not s big place like The Cheesecake Factory.) When a meal can be $30+ per person with drink and tip and you’re given paper napkins and canned sodas, the wait staff needs to bridge the gap and ensure the dining experience aligns with the price point.