Best Pizzerias in Cedar Grove

Olio e Pui was a lovely place to take my out of town guest for lunch on January 4, 2025. The food was excellent and the selection absolutely to our taste.

I was so excited to have a chance to dine at Emilys while I was in NY. I got the burger because Dax Shepard talks about it so often on the Armchair Expert podcast and it did not disappoint!! It was so delicious and the waffle fries were also crispy and seasoned perfectly! I’m already looking forward to my next visit so I can have it again.

One of the best Italian restaurants in the city. Delicious food, amazing staff, and fun energy. Worth the wait on Friday and Saturday nights for a table!

Unquestionably the best pizza I've ever had in my 40 years of heavily Italian-cultural NYC Italian-American life, including many visits to Italy.

We have been to Eataly both in Soho and Boston and have eaten at both. We enjoyed being able to Eataly closer to our home. For lunch today we had the Burata con Caponata. The burrata was creamy and deliciious and the caponata was well seasoned and enhanced the burrata experience. We had an order of Ravioli di Zucca. The pasta was sublime, the butter and sage sauce lightly coated the pasta that was tender with a flavorful butternut squash filling. We also order the Baccala (pan-seared cod) over roasted butternut squash. The serving portion was a good size and we perfectly roasted. The accompanying butternut squash was a nice contrast to the code. Our server was lovely and personable and made our dining experience enjoyable. We'll be back.