4 Best Pizza Bars In Fishers Island

4 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Vico: Pasta e Pizza Napoletano restaurant

1. Vico: Pasta e Pizza Napoletano

4.5

Price: Moderate

• Pizza Bar • Farmingdale

Booked 4 times today

Vico: Pasta e Pizza Napoletano in Farmingdale is more than just a restaurant; it’s a vibrant cocktail bar where every drink tells a story of creativity and Italian authenticity. Guests rave about the cocktails, describing them as "on point" and the best they've had at any bar across Long Island. The skilled bartenders at Vico mix classic and innovative cocktails that perfectly complement their exquisite Italian dishes. The ambiance, inspired by the Amalfi Coast, sets a perfect backdrop for enjoying these finely crafted beverages. With glowing reviews highlighting the exceptional service and the high-quality ingredients, Vico stands out as a must-visit destination for cocktail enthusiasts seeking a taste of Italy in Farmingdale.

2. Mangia E Bevi

4.2

Awesome(33)

Price: Moderate

• Pizza Bar • Massapequa

Booked 22 times today

Introducing the all-new Mangia E Bevi, where passion meets perfection in every dish. Under new ownership, our Italian restaurant has undergone a complete renovation to bring you a dining experience like no other. From the charming ambiance to the exquisite flavors of our authentic Italian cuisine, every detail has been crafted to delight your senses. We can't wait for you to dine with us and savor the taste of tradition with a fresh twist.

3. Ella's

4.3

Awesome(137)

Price: Expensive

• Pizza Bar • Huntington

Booked 4 times today

Ella's, nestled in the vibrant heart of Huntington Village, is a celebrated destination for pizza enthusiasts and food lovers alike. Renowned for its wood-fired pizzas and locally sourced ingredients, Ella's stands out with its exceptional Pizza Bar. Guests rave about the gluten-free options, noting the crust is "the closest to regular pizza crust" they've found, catering superbly to those with dietary sensitivities. The innovative "Dark Side of the Moon" pizza, with smoked duck and caramelized onions, is a standout, showcasing Ella's commitment to unique, flavorful combinations. Whether it's a casual meal before a show at the nearby Paramount or a leisurely dinner, Ella's provides a consistently amazing experience with "excellent pizzas!!! Fresh, innovative and delicious!" making it a must-visit for anyone seeking authentic and high-quality pizza.

A photo of 1653 Pizza Company restaurant

4. 1653 Pizza Company

4.5

Awesome(141)

Price: Expensive

• Pizza Bar • Huntington

Booked 5 times today

1653 Pizza Company in Huntington Village stands out as a beacon of authentic Italian cuisine, celebrated for its coal-fired pizzas that transport diners straight to Italy. Guests rave about the "best pizza in Huntington" and appreciate the fresh, quality ingredients that make every bite memorable. One reviewer shared, "It made me feel like I was back in Italy," underscoring the restaurant's commitment to authentic flavors. The seasonal menu updates keep the offerings exciting, and the skilled mixologists elevate the dining experience with creative cocktails. Whether for a romantic date night or a family gathering, 1653 Pizza Company promises an unforgettable Italian culinary adventure.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Best Pizza Bars in Fishers Island

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

4 restaurants available nearby

1. Vico: Pasta e Pizza Napoletano

2. Mangia E Bevi

3. Ella's

4. 1653 Pizza Company

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable