Best Italian Restaurants in Waukesha

Service took longer than usual but I figured they were busy the day after Valentine’s Day.

Maggianos @ Mayfair is consistently wonderful! Every associate from the hostess to Host Mitchell to server Brietta exhibited professionalism, warmth and kindness. What I would describe as “Agape Love”. We look forward to our dinners there and are never disappointed. The food is bountiful and delicious:)

This restaurant is very quaint, with a wonderful ambiance. The staff is very friendly and knowledgeable about the menu and food. We were here for Valentine's Day and had a great experience. I can't compliment the food enough! My husband and I ordered all different food and everything was exceptional! We would not hesitate to come here again. If you love good food, and being treated special while you're eating it, this is your place!

The food was good, the setting was romantic and lighting was great, however the Valentine’s special was just a little misleading, we could have used more guidance as to what was included in the special

The menu was very impressive, with multiple options that my wife I were eager to try. Our waitress was incredibly attentive and helped us decide on what to get. After ordering appetizers, pasta, desserts, and multiple drinks I was also surprised that the bill was lower than I expected, especially for the quality of everything. We will definitely return.