Best Italian Restaurants in Vestal

I travel an hour to come here. Best Italian in NYS!

Food was generally good except for the spaghetti. I believe it was homemade but it was too chewy. Not a good texture. The pappardelle was tasty though. Service was good although a little slow.

Lovely ambiance and excellent service. The staff were friendly and welcoming. We ordered two "classic" Italian main dishes (eggplant parm with homemade spaghetti) and they were very tasty. The marinara sauce was especially good. Our son ordered salmon and was very pleased. He also had an appetizer of meatballs and thought they were great. And the foccacia bread is wonderful! Our only suggestion for improvement would be to "beef up" the salads that accompany the main dishes. The baby lettuce was appreciated (instead of a few pieces of soggy iceberg that you get in other restaurants) but the portion was very meager and included one olive, two small cherry tomatoes and just a tiny bit of lettuce.

Food was great. Waitress was great. Highly reccomend.

The service and food are always excellent at Tony’s! During these unusual times it is very comforting to be able to dine out knowing everything will follow the guidelines exactly!! Nicely done Jared Miller and staff!!