Best Italian Restaurants in San Carlos Park

16 restaurants available nearby

A photo of San Matteo Italian Restaurant & Bar restaurant

1. San Matteo Italian Restaurant & Bar

4.5

Price: Expensive

• Italian • San Carlos Park

Booked 29 times today

San Matteo Italian Restaurant & Bar in San Carlos Park, Fort Myers, truly stands out as a premier destination for authentic Neapolitan-style pizza. Praised for its "phenomenal" quality and authenticity, the restaurant offers a slice of Italy with its award-winning pizzas that are a delight to both locals and visitors. Guests rave about the Margherita and Napoli pizzas, noting they are "just like the pizza we had in Naples." The secret lies in the ingredients, with flour imported directly from Italy, ensuring each bite is as authentic as it is delicious. Coupled with a vibrant atmosphere and exceptional service, San Matteo is the go-to place for anyone craving genuine Italian pizza. This pizzeria is not just a meal; it's an experience that brings a piece of Italy right to your table.

2. 41 Bistro

4.8

Exceptional(265)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • San Carlos Park

Booked 24 times today

41 Bistro in San Carlos Park, Fort Myers, is a culinary haven for steak lovers. This exceptional dining spot combines Italian flair with the art of steak preparation, ensuring each dish is a masterpiece. Patrons rave about the quality, with one guest proclaiming the steak as "very good," highlighting its prominence alongside other Italian specialties. The restaurant's dedication to fine ingredients and skillful cooking shines through, making every steak dish a delectable journey of flavors. Whether it's a romantic dinner or a special gathering, 41 Bistro promises an unforgettable steak experience that keeps guests coming back for more. Celebrate your next steak dinner at 41 Bistro, where tradition meets excellence.

3. Pezzo Pizza + Bar

4.6

Exceptional(63)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Estero

Booked 10 times today

At Pezzo Pizza + Bar in Estero, the essence of Italian cuisine comes alive with every dish crafted by Head Chef Crecenzo DePasquale, straight from Napoli. The restaurant is renowned for its "authentic Italian Kitchen" where every ingredient is chosen with care to create "gourmet pizzas" and "delicious" craft cocktails. The glowing reviews highlight the "best pizza I have had in SWFL" and the "labor and love" that go into dishes like hand-stuffed Lobster Raviolis and a daily hand-pressed dough. Diners rave about the "unique dining experience" and the "great atmosphere" that make Pezzo a top choice for anyone craving a true taste of Italy. Whether it's the "amazing" Lobster Ravioli or the "crisp and fresh" pizzas with a perfect char, Pezzo Pizza + Bar delivers an unforgettable Italian feast.

A photo of Ristorante Farfalla restaurant

4. Ristorante Farfalla

4.4

Awesome(1446)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Estero

Booked 4 times today

Ristorante Farfalla in Estero is a celebrated gem for steak lovers. Known for its nationally acclaimed cuisine, the restaurant offers a steak experience that is both authentic and exceptional. Diners consistently rave about their meals, with one guest highlighting, "Dinner with friends our table enjoyed pasta, salmon, chicken and steak. Delicious meals at fair price." The chef's commitment to quality and the skilled staff ensure each steak is cooked to perfection, promising a memorable dining experience. Whether it's a special occasion or a casual dinner, Ristorante Farfalla stands out as a top choice for steak enthusiasts in the Estero area.

A photo of Caffe' da Michele LLC restaurant

5. Caffe' da Michele LLC

3.4

Very Good(113)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • San Carlos Park

Booked 1 time today

"Caffe' da Michele Osteria Italiana is bringing traditional Favorites homemade Italian fare, such as Fettuccine Bolognese, Rigatoni all' Amatriciana and Lasagna di Carne"

A photo of Zino Neighborhood Restaurant restaurant

6. Zino Neighborhood Restaurant

4.6

Exceptional(32)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Estero

Booked 1 time today

Dive into the heart of Estero, FL, and discover Zino Neighborhood Restaurant, a gem that serves up authentic Italian cuisine with a creative twist. Praised for its "delicious carefully prepared food" and vibrant atmosphere, Zino stands out with its Italian offerings like the much-loved Chicken Parmesan and the uniquely delightful Pear Fiocchi. Guests rave about the "outstanding" live music and atmosphere, making every dining experience memorable. As one reviewer puts it, Zino is "very inviting and the food is delish." Perfect for family and friends, Zino promises not just a meal but an experience, complete with "great service" and a "friendly neighborhood" vibe. Whether it's the Italian classics or innovative dishes, Zino's authenticity and quality are unmistakable.

A photo of Angelina's Ristorante restaurant

7. Angelina's Ristorante

4.8

Exceptional(5664)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bonita Springs

Booked 58 times today

Benvenuti Angelina’s! Thank you for choosing Angelina’s. We serve only the finest products available, from Wagyu steaks to our hand-made pastas and rustic house-baked bread. Our Chef utilizes the freshest ingredients to create a culinary experience unlike any other. For table requests and special event reservations, please call 239-390-3187. We do not take reservations for Happy Hour, we seat Happy Hour on a first come, first serve basis. Consistently awarded Wine Spectator Magazine's 2-glass and Best of Award of Excellence, and our wine menu was developed to complement and enhance your menu choices. Our highly-qualified staff and Sommelier can assist you in choosing that perfect bottle of wine. Our dress code is Business Casual, no casual shorts and no open-toed shoes for men. Dressy denim with a dressy top is acceptable, but please always dress to impress when you choose Angelina's.

A photo of DeRomo's Gourmet Market & Restaurant restaurant

8. DeRomo's Gourmet Market & Restaurant

4.6

Exceptional(5364)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bonita Springs

Booked 87 times today

DeRomo's Gourmet Market and Restaurant offers a fun, sophisticated, and casual dining atmosphere like no other with an open-style kitchen design, private dining room to accommodate small private parties for up to 20 guests. All of our dishes are prepared with our fresh-cut meats, seafood, produce and other ingredients from our Gourmet Market. From innovative, decadent entrees to your favorite comfort foods and traditional dishes, our world class trained chefs are sure to satisfy the most discretionary palette & keep your heart coming back for more.DeRomo's Gourmet Market and Restaurant brings the flavor and feel of Little Italy to Southwest Florida. A warm, friendly and creative environment coupled with a fresh, authentic home style cuisine, will make you feel at home.We appreciate your reservation and will do our best to accommodate your request. We guarantee a table not the location.

A photo of Terra Nostra Restaurant restaurant

9. Terra Nostra Restaurant

4.9

Exceptional(2054)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Fort Myers Beach

Booked 45 times today

Terra Nostra Restaurant near Fort Myers Beach delivers an exceptional seafood dining experience that consistently impresses both locals and visitors. Renowned for its "delicious" seafood offerings, guests rave about dishes like the succulent grouper, praised for its freshness and superb seasoning. The restaurant's location just minutes from Sanibel adds a charming allure, perfect for enjoying seafood fresh from the nearby waters. Patrons often highlight the excellent service, with comments such as "the food and service were amazing!" and "service was excellent." Terra Nostra's commitment to quality and an enchanting dining environment makes it a standout destination for seafood lovers seeking authenticity and excellence in Fort Myers.

10. Mastello

4.8

Exceptional(462)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Fort Myers

Booked 29 times today

Mastello in Fort Myers is a gem for those seeking a premier steakhouse experience. Located conveniently near the Barbara B. Mann Theatre, this elegantly revamped venue is celebrated for its prime cuts and American Wagyu, ensuring a top-tier dining indulgence. Patrons rave about the "most delicious and well-seasoned filets" and the "perfectly prepared Wagyu top cut sirloin," highlighting the exceptional quality of the meats. With over 100 wine selections and a sophisticated cocktail bar, Mastello not only promises a delightful meal but a luxurious atmosphere perfect for any special occasion. As one diner put it, this is the place for "an upscale evening out," making every visit to Mastello a memorable feast of flavors and impeccable service.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

T
Terri
Philadelphia County •3 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
Lovely evening. Waitress Natalie was super attentive and positive! Food, as always, delicious and thoroughly enjoyed! Thank you for another wonderful experience! Happy New Year!
More info
San Matteo Italian Restaurant & BarPrice: Expensive• Contemporary Italian• San Carlos Park
•
4.5
D
Danielle
Indiana •3 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
We went on Christmas Day for dinner. Even though we made a reservation, there was, understandably, a little wait for our table. We thought, for a holiday, that a half hour wait for the table was acceptable, even though others complained. My husband ordered the pasta Bolognese and practically licked the bowl! I ordered the ribs, which was indeed a full rack, and...oh...my...gosh. Not only was there an amazing dry rub, the sauce was really good, too. Let me tell you, they were actually fall-of-the-bone ribs! We appreciated not being rushed out once our meal was complete and even ordered dessert! Our server was attentive and kind, and our meal was even delivered by a robot cat! This place may not look like much from the outside but we were really glad we stopped!!
More info
41 BistroPrice: Moderate• Italian• San Carlos Park
•
4.8
P
PhilVIP
Minneapolis - St. Paul •22 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
The Christmas menu was extensive with great variety. This is a top notch restaurant and the food rivals any other great restaurant in SWFL. Great value, great food, good service, good ambience.
More info
Ristorante FarfallaPrice: Moderate• Italian• Estero
•
4.4
A
A. ErnestVIP
Southwest Florida •605 reviews
4.0
Dined on Dec 16, 2024
This was our fourth visit and I can be a little food picky so obviously I like the food here. I do find the noise level more than I can handle but the restaurant is always busy so people must not mind how Loud it can be. The personal size pizza’s are always good and a great value. We always end up taking pizza home. I especially like their meatballs. Tonight I tried eggplant rollatini, rolled with prosciutto which was different and a treat.
More info
Pezzo Pizza + BarPrice: Moderate• Pizza Bar• Estero
•
4.6
S
steven
Minneapolis - St. Paul •1 review
4.0
Dined on Sep 28, 2024
Good food, good service, great music videos in the background. Not noisy. We will be back again for a music event dinner.
More info
Zino Neighborhood RestaurantPrice: Moderate• American• Estero
•
4.6

Explore OpenTable

San Carlos Park

Italian

Best Italian Restaurants in San Carlos Park

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

16 restaurants available nearby

1. San Matteo Italian Restaurant & Bar

2. 41 Bistro

3. Pezzo Pizza + Bar

4. Ristorante Farfalla

5. Caffe' da Michele LLC

6. Zino Neighborhood Restaurant

7. Angelina's Ristorante

8. DeRomo's Gourmet Market & Restaurant

9. Terra Nostra Restaurant

10. Mastello

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable