Best Italian Restaurants in North York / Don Mills

It was my first time but it wont be my last. Food and service were amazing! Place romantic but familiar. Perfect for 5th anniversary occasion.

We were 5 and we all enjoyed our dinners very much. We had pizza, pasta, fish and Caesar and all were very tasty and generous portions. So much so there will little bags going home with us. The service was friendly and very professional. We have been to Oretta many times and we will be back many more times.

We came to Parcheggio for Valentine’s Day dinner and had a wonderful experience. Service was exceptional and the ambiance was perfectly set for date night. We appreciated the effort they put into every small detail to make the experience special, like the great Valentine’s Day playlist and the free flowers they provided to gift to your date- very cute and made our Valentine’s date night very memorable! We chose from the Valentine’s Day prix fixe menu, and all the dishes were amazing. Our favourite was the tiramisu for dessert- one of the best we’ve tried. Highly recommend!

THE FOOD, AS ALWAYS, WAS EXCELLENT AND THE SERVICE OUTSTANDING. OUR HOSTESS WENT OUT OF HER WAY TO FIND A TABLE SUITABLE FOR MYSELF AND MY WIFE. BECAUSE I AM IN A WHEELCHAIR, I REQUIRE A SPACE WHERE MY WIFE COULD SIT BESIDE ME ON A HIGH STOOL TO MAKE IT EASIER FOR HER TO FEED ME. THE SERVER WAS ALWAYS THERE AT AN APPROPRIATE TIME. WE NEVER FELT RUSHED, BUT WE NEVER FELT NEGLECTED. THE ENTIRE EXPERIENCE FELT COMFORTABLE AND WELCOME.

Overall the experience was great. The atmosphere was lovely, the food was delicious, and most of the staff were fantastic polite, professional, and even had a great sense of humor, which made the evening enjoyable. Unfortunately, one server’s behavior negatively impacted our experience. From the beginning, she seemed dismissive, frequently responding to our requests with “huh?” or “what?” sometimes making us repeat ourselves unnecessarily. While this could have been due to noise, it didn’t happen consistently, making it feel intentional, as though she was mocking my friend’s English. I may be wrong. The real issue, however, was her unprofessional attitude. At one point, she openly mimicked my friend just a few steps away from us, which was completely inappropriate. When she didn’t receive a tip, instead of reflecting on her service, she confronted us, sarcastically asking if there was a problem and even offering to bring the manager so we could "file a complaint." Tipping is based on service quality, and while the rest of the staff was excellent, her attitude made it impossible to justify leaving one. Despite this, we had a wonderful time thanks to the great food and the exceptional service from the other staff members. I hope management addresses such behavior to maintain the restaurant’s otherwise excellent reputation.