Best Italian Restaurants in Mercer Island

63 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Carmine's - Bellevue restaurant

1. Carmine's - Bellevue

4.8

Exceptional(2747)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bellevue

Booked 57 times today

From the owners of Il Terrazzo Carmine, one of Seattle"s most iconic and beloved establishments, comes Carmine's Bellevue. Carmine's Bellevue brings to the east side the same level of quality in service, food, and ambiance that has made its sister restaurant a true institution in Downtown Seattle. Located at 88 102nd Avenue in Bellevue's historic Old Bellevue neighborhood, Carmines is nestled against Bellevue Park. With a rustic, timeless interior, Carmine's provides patrons an escape from the increasingly urbanized way of life. Upscale and elegant, Carmine's feels anything but stiff and pretentious. Good for business meetings, special occasions, or simply dining with loved ones, Carmine's Bellevue is a true destination on the east side.

2. Bis on Main

4.6

Exceptional(1969)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bellevue

Booked 24 times today

Bis on Main in Bellevue is a culinary gem, renowned for its authentic American cuisine, including exceptional seafood, sumptuous steaks, and the much-loved Crispy Garlic Chicken. Patrons rave about the "wonderful food selections" and "stellar food quality," highlighting the restaurant's commitment to excellence. The cozy ambience and friendly staff add to the dining experience, with one reviewer noting, "The food and service was outstanding. It was nice to see the chef in the dining room." Whether it's for a romantic date night, a celebratory brunch, or a casual fine dining experience, Bis on Main consistently impresses with its "delicious dinner" and "perfect service," making it a must-visit for anyone seeking top-notch American fare in Bellevue.

3. Spinasse

4.7

Exceptional(3798)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Capitol Hill / First Hill

Booked 39 times today

Spinasse in Seattle's vibrant Capitol Hill / First Hill neighborhood stands as a beacon of Italian culinary excellence. Renowned for its handcrafted pastas, such as the "simply outstanding" Tarjin and "heavenly" butter sage pasta, this restaurant ensures a memorable dining experience with every dish. Visitors rave about the delicate, perfectly prepared pasta, describing it as "a spiritual experience" and "the best pasta you will ever taste." Spinasse's atmosphere is equally praised, offering a warm, inviting setting that complements its exquisite Piedmont-inspired menu. Whether it's the "amazing" service or the "incredible" food, Spinasse consistently delivers an enchanting taste of Italy, making it a must-visit destination for both locals and tourists alike.

A photo of Cantinetta - Bellevue restaurant

4. Cantinetta - Bellevue

4.8

Exceptional(1245)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Bellevue

Booked 15 times today

We are an Italian restaurant and bar located in Bellevue. We emphasize Tuscan culinary traditions and seasonal organic ingredients from the Pacific Northwest.

A photo of That's Amore - Seattle restaurant

5. That's Amore - Seattle

4.7

Exceptional(1120)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Leschi / Madrona / Madison Park

Booked 20 times today

At That's Amore in Seattle, the dessert offerings are as stunning as the city views from its tables. Patrons rave about the authenticity and exceptional taste of the desserts, with the tiramisu and cannoli receiving special mentions. One review exclaimed, “We tried all of the dessert but the cannoli, and that was my favorite part.” Another diner highlighted the affogato with pistachio gelato, calling it “amazing on its own but even better with the espresso!” The attention to quality and detail in each dessert item ensures a delightful finish to every meal at That's Amore, making it a must-visit for those with a sweet tooth in the Leschi/Madrona/Madison Park neighborhood.

6. Vendemmia

4.7

Exceptional(1123)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Leschi / Madrona / Madison Park

Booked 13 times today

Vendemmia, nestled in Seattle’s vibrant Madrona neighborhood, truly stands out with its authentic farm-to-table cuisine. Renowned for its devotion to local produce and house-made pastas, every dish is a testament to freshness and quality. Patrons rave about the "excellent and first-class Italian cuisine" and highlight seasonal favorites like the "snap pea and crab salad" and the "best spaghetti pomodoro anywhere." Its warm, neighborhood ambiance is complemented by an attentive service and a carefully curated wine list focused on Pacific Northwest and European producers. Whether it's the "fantastic food" or the "divine craft cocktails," Vendemmia consistently provides a delightful dining experience that celebrates the essence of farm-to-table dining.

A photo of Il Terrazzo Carmine restaurant

7. Il Terrazzo Carmine

4.8

Exceptional(4078)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Pioneer Square

Booked 40 times today

Il Terrazzo Carmine, owned and operated by Carmine Smeraldo, is one of Seattle's true dining anomalies - a highly successful restaurant with unfailingly high standards and a loyal, sophisticated clientele. The cuisine has been acclaimed as Seattle's best by the media and more importantly, by local diners. Il Terrazzo Carmine is located in historic Pioneer Square - nestled in an urban-renewed alley with entrances through the vintage lobby on First Avenue or through the delightful courtyard in the back. Since 1984, Carmine Smeraldo's classic Italian restaurant has been where the locals have chosen to return over and over again. From the Carpaccio Di Bue and Spaghettini Dell 'Ortolano for lunch to the Suprema Di Pollo Farcita and Zuppa Di Pesce for dinner you will know you have gone to a place where excellence is a way of life. Arguably the best Italian restaurant in Seattle, Il Terrazzo serves classical Italian cuisine with an atmosphere you may want to call home and never leave

A photo of Tutta Bella - Columbia City restaurant

8. Tutta Bella - Columbia City

4.7

Exceptional(115)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Columbia City

Booked 9 times today

Tutta Bella in Columbia City, Seattle, stands as a beacon of authentic Italian cuisine. Nestled in a vibrant, historic neighborhood, this flagship restaurant is renowned for its fine Neapolitan pizza and a delightful array of pastas, salads, and desserts. Diners consistently praise the high-quality, wood-fired pizzas, noting the crust as "one of the top 3 I've ever had" — thin, crispy, and perfectly sturdy. The ambiance is warmly described as both modern and inviting, ideal for any gathering. Notably, the restaurant's commitment to the community and excellent service repeatedly earns it rave reviews, with guests celebrating its "very authentic Italian food" and spirited atmosphere. Whether it's the bustling bar area, the cozy patio on a sunny day, or the intimate loft space, Tutta Bella offers a slice of Italy right in the heart of Seattle.

9. Tulio

4.7

Exceptional(4102)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Downtown

Booked 33 times today

Nestled in the heart of Downtown Seattle, Tulio stands out as a beacon of Italian culinary excellence, renowned for its authentic Northern Italian dishes crafted by the acclaimed Chef Walter Pisano. Praised for fusing rustic Italian techniques with fresh local ingredients, Tulio has consistently earned accolades for its bold flavors and innovative cuisine. Guests rave about signature dishes like the "sweet potato gnocchi in fried sage butter" and the "best roast chicken with risotto" they've ever tasted. With options for every dietary need, including gluten-free and vegan choices, Tulio caters to all without compromising on taste. As one reviewer enthused, it's "hands-down our favorite restaurant...the food is always exceptional, as is the service." Tulio is truly a must-visit for an unforgettable Italian dining experience in Seattle.

A photo of Tutta Bella - Wallingford restaurant

10. Tutta Bella - Wallingford

4.5

Awesome(133)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Wallingford

Booked 22 times today

Tutta Bella in Wallingford, Seattle, is a gem for lovers of authentic Neapolitan pizza. Celebrated for its use of traditional wood-fired ovens named Pietro and Filomena, Tutta Bella crafts pizzas that truly honor the culinary heritage of Naples, intertwined with vibrant Pacific Northwest influences. Guests rave about the quality, with one admirer noting, "the pizzas were so fresh and light, and the thin crust was perfection." The atmosphere is equally praised, suitable for both festive family gatherings and casual drinks at the "Jewel Box" bar. Whether it's the praised Roberto pizza or the fresh, seasonal options, Tutta Bella stands out as a top destination for Pizzeria cuisine in Seattle.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

V
Venky
Seattle / Eastern Washington •6 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
Really enjoyed the food and ambience at Spinasse. There were good options on the menu for a vegetarian family. Our waiter, Heather was awesome and very knowledgeable about vegetarian choices and helped make the right choices. A little bit disappointed that 2 desserts on the menu contain pork gelatin, but there were 3 other desserts to choose from. Again, Heather was awesome in steering us in the right direction. Overall a great experience for a special family dinner!
More info
SpinassePrice: Very Expensive• Italian• Capitol Hill / First Hill
•
4.7
A
angelle
Seattle / Eastern Washington •25 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
Carmine’s is one of the best food experiences we have had in awhile! Service was exceptional, the lobster pasta special was a dream, the fillet with gnocchi was lovely. And the bread pudding was amazing. Thank you for a great evening. We will be back!
More info
Carmine's - BellevuePrice: Expensive• Italian• Bellevue
•
4.8
M
michelleVIP
Seattle / Eastern Washington •20 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
Our favorite place over the years! We love how the restaurant is tucked into the main building and the secure parking garage below. The food is always perfect and the staff knows exactly what wine to pair. We love the bar since it’s cozy and the tables have a bench seat on one side. The bar is beautiful and perfectly lit. The dessert tray is the best - we love how they bring it over so you can see what each one is!
More info
Il Terrazzo CarminePrice: Expensive• Italian• Pioneer Square
•
4.8
E
EricVIP
Seattle / Eastern Washington •13 reviews
5.0
Dined 4 days ago
Fabulous meal, great service, and reasonably priced. Will return.
More info
Bis on MainPrice: Expensive• Northwest• Bellevue
•
4.6
S
SheriVIP
Seattle / Eastern Washington •13 reviews
5.0
Dined on Dec 17, 2024
My spouse and I celebrate all our special occasions at That’s Amore, birthdays, anniversaries, other celebrations. We love the owners and staff as well as the food and beautiful city view. The food is prepared with care and every bite is delicious!
More info
That's Amore - SeattlePrice: Expensive• Italian• Leschi / Madrona / Madison Park
•
4.7

Explore OpenTable

Mercer Island

Italian

Best Italian Restaurants in Mercer Island

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

63 restaurants available nearby

1. Carmine's - Bellevue

2. Bis on Main

3. Spinasse

4. Cantinetta - Bellevue

5. That's Amore - Seattle

6. Vendemmia

7. Il Terrazzo Carmine

8. Tutta Bella - Columbia City

9. Tulio

10. Tutta Bella - Wallingford

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable