6 Best Italian Restaurants In Cole Bay

6 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Roma Restaurant Cucina Italiana restaurant

1. Roma Restaurant Cucina Italiana

4.9

Exceptional(299)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Simpson Bay

Booked 13 times today

At Roma Restaurant Cucina Italiana, nestled in the vibrant Maho Village of Simpson Bay, you'll experience a slice of Italy with every dish. Helmed by Chef Matteo, a Rome native, the restaurant is celebrated for its "authentic Italian food that will knock your socks off." Patrons rave about the divine dishes, with one noting, "The food was divine, reminding us of the exquisite food we enjoyed as we toured Italy!" From the cozy, classy atmosphere to the fresh, high-quality ingredients sourced directly from Italy, every detail at Roma ensures an authentic dining experience. Whether you're enjoying a meal in the main dining room or the garden 'Al Fresco,' Roma promises an "unforgettable dining experience" that keeps guests coming back.

2. Tortuga Maho

4.6

Exceptional(63)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Simpson Bay

Booked 12 times today

At Tortuga Maho, located in the picturesque Simpson Bay near Maho Beach, diners are treated to an exceptional showcase of International cuisine, complemented by breathtaking views of the Caribbean. This gem offers a diverse menu that captures the essence of global flavors, ensuring a tantalizing experience for all palates. Patrons rave about the quality and authenticity of the dishes, with one guest exclaiming, “Great food, great service, ocean view, watch the planes fly in, and not super packed.” Another highlighted the restaurant’s standout dishes, saying, “The tuna burger was fantastic!” The superb service, coupled with the unique ambiance of watching planes land, makes Tortuga Maho a top destination for those seeking a remarkable dining experience in St. Maarten.

3. Amore

new

3.4

Very Good(3)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Simpson Bay

Booked 3 times today

Welcome to our Caribbean / Italian restaurant, where we blend the vibrant flavors of the Caribbean and the traditional tastes of Italy to create a unique and unforgettable dining experience. Our menu offers of two rich culinary traditions, featuring dishes that showcase the bold spices and fresh ingredients of the Caribbean alongside the classic pasta, pizza, and seafood dishes of Italy. Whether you're craving a conchs, oxtail, chicken pasta or a savory seafood risotto, our talented chefs are dedicated to bringing you the best of both worlds. Join us for a culinary journey that will transport your taste buds to the sunny shores of the Caribbean and the charming streets of Italy. Buon appetito!

4. Liguria

4.3

Awesome(11)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Oyster Pond

Booked 3 times today

Welcome to Liguria! Fine dining restaurant offering a Coastal Mediterranean gastronomic experience featuring the robust coastal flavors of Italy and France.

A photo of La Rosa Italian Restaurant restaurant

5. La Rosa Italian Restaurant

4.6

Exceptional(13)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Simpson Bay

La Rosa Italian Restaurant, located in the picturesque Simpson Bay in the Lowlands, is a treasure trove of authentic Seafood cuisine blended masterfully with Italian flair. Guests rave about the "Spicy Fisherman's Soup" and the fresh seafood options, describing them as "the best dish I had on the island during my week stay." La Rosa's commitment to quality is evident in their use of fresh ingredients and expert preparation, ensuring every dish is memorable. Diners consistently praise the restaurant, noting the "wonderfully spiced sauce" in the homemade fettuccine with shrimp and the overall "amazing" food quality. Whether you're dining on the expanded veranda or inside the cozy, air-conditioned interior, La Rosa promises an exceptional seafood dining experience, making it a must-visit destination for both locals and visitors.

A photo of Oliva – Aurora Anguilla Resort restaurant

6. Oliva – Aurora Anguilla Resort

4.3

Awesome(10)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Anguilla

Booked 1 time today

We are situated on the grounds of the beautiful Aurora Anguilla Resort & Golf Club. We welcome all guests from other resorts and hotels on the island as well as the general public.Caribbean and Italian flavors fuse at this elegant and inviting eatery. Lively ambiance and scenic water views provide a picture perfect backdrop for an unforgettable meal.For large bookings please contact our hotel concierge at concierge@auroraanguilla.com.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Best Italian Restaurants in Cole Bay

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

6 restaurants available nearby

1. Roma Restaurant Cucina Italiana

2. Tortuga Maho

3. Amore

4. Liguria

5. La Rosa Italian Restaurant

6. Oliva – Aurora Anguilla Resort

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable