Best Italian Restaurants in Bainbridge Island

40 restaurants available nearby

1. The Pink Door

4.8

Exceptional(8934)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Belltown / Pike Place Market

Booked 126 times today

The Pink Door is an independently owned (never cloned, never genetically modified) restaurant that has been quietly dedicated to fresh & local Italian food since 1981. Its seafood & produce driven menu has been the central theme throughout its wildly popular domain in Seattle's Pike Place Market.

2. San Fermo

4.8

Exceptional(1621)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Ballard

Booked 29 times today

We have 15 indoor tables, and 12 covered/heated patio tables. Online reservations can be made for parties up to 5 guests. Larger groups can be booked at 5pm on weeknights, please email the restaurant for reservations. Please understand when making your reservation that we cannot guarantee a specific table or area of the restaurant. We recommend 5pm reservations for parties with specific table requests, if you book later in the evening you may need to wait for your table preference.If you are having difficulty finding a reservation you are welcome to stop by for walk-in seating. We seat our bar and covered/heated patio for dinner nightly.

A photo of Mondello Ristorante Italiano restaurant

3. Mondello Ristorante Italiano

4.8

Exceptional(472)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Magnolia

Booked 3 times today

Mondello Italian Restaurant in the beautiful Seattle neighborhood of Magnolia provides one of the most romantic, most authentic Italian dining experiences in Seattle. Mondello has beautiful pasta dishes, seafood & main courses, salads, zuppe & bruschette & antipasti dishes. Corino (owner) & Enza (chef) grew up in the vicinity of Mondello and they bring to Seattle their wonderful tradition of fresh seafood, homemade pasta & rich authentic Sicilian cuisine with all it's flair & joy of living. They have the life experience of fine cooking and appreciation & sensiblity of the Italian palate that allows them to create a dining experience reminiscent of being in Mondello, Sicily. No one fails to be entranced by Mondello's welcoming beauty and warm personality.Grazie Amici!

4. Messina

4.0

Excellent(273)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Queen Anne

Booked 39 times today

Messina Modern Italian Kitchen is a vibrant gem nestled in the heart of Queen Anne, Seattle, offering an exquisite blend of Contemporary Italian cuisine infused with Pacific Northwest flavors. Diners rave about the "unbelievable" food and "fantastic" pasta, making it a must-visit for those seeking authentic Italian with a modern twist. The atmosphere is lively yet intimate, perfect for any occasion, from romantic date nights to pre-event dinners. Guests are consistently impressed by the "extraordinary" service and the staff's attention to detail, often noting that the experience feels "like a special occasion." Messina's dedication to quality and authenticity truly sets it apart.

5. Stoneburner

4.8

Exceptional(1691)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Ballard

Booked 24 times today

Stoneburner in Ballard, Seattle, is a beacon of exceptional Vegetarian cuisine, blending the rich flavors of the Mediterranean with the fresh produce of the Pacific Northwest. Diners rave about the restaurant's "phenomenal" dishes, crafted meticulously with high-quality ingredients and served with a flair that is both authentic and innovative. The stone hearth cooking method infuses each dish with a unique, rustic charm, making every meal memorable. Guests frequently highlight the inviting ambiance and top-notch service, with one review noting, "From the moment we arrived, the restaurant exceeded our expectations." Stoneburner promises a delightful vegetarian experience that keeps patrons returning for more.

A photo of Artusi (21 and over) restaurant

6. Artusi (21 and over)

4.6

Exceptional(79)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Capitol Hill / First Hill

Booked 3 times today

Artusi is 21 and olderCome enjoy our pasta and wine night on Sunday and Monday, and Industry night on Tuesday with 10% off. Chef Stuart Lane creates a casual menu offering including our multi award winning meatballs. We only accept reservations for parties of 3 or more, we encourage parties of 1 or 2 to walk in! On Sunday/Monday night, we do not accept any reservations and operate just on a walk in basis.

7. Grappa - Seattle

4.7

Exceptional(1214)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Queen Anne

Booked 17 times today

Grappa - Seattle is a seafood lover's paradise located in the vibrant Queen Anne neighborhood. Renowned for its exceptional Mediterranean-inspired dishes, the restaurant offers a seafood experience that is both authentic and exquisite. Diners rave about the "delicious seafood risotto," which is creamy and tender, featuring perfectly cooked salmon and prawns. Another standout is their "ridiculously good paella," a harmonious blend of chicken and seafood that leaves a lasting impression on patrons. The consistently high quality of their seafood, paired with an inviting atmosphere and exceptional customer service, makes Grappa a must-visit destination for seafood enthusiasts.

8. Spinasse

4.8

Exceptional(3802)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Capitol Hill / First Hill

Booked 34 times today

Spinasse, nestled in Seattle's vibrant Capitol Hill, is a beacon of authentic Organic cuisine, celebrated for its exceptional quality and remarkable dining experiences. Diners rave about the "incredible food with lots of North Italian influences," highlighting the standout butter and sage pasta as a must-try. The restaurant's commitment to using fresh, organic ingredients is evident in every dish, from exquisite tajarin to sumptuous crab risotto, which guests describe as “one of the best dishes” they've ever had. With a warm ambiance and attentive service, Spinasse offers a delightful culinary journey that leaves diners eagerly planning their next visit.

A photo of Il Terrazzo Carmine restaurant

9. Il Terrazzo Carmine

4.8

Exceptional(4083)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Pioneer Square

Booked 35 times today

Il Terrazzo Carmine, owned and operated by Carmine Smeraldo, is one of Seattle's true dining anomalies - a highly successful restaurant with unfailingly high standards and a loyal, sophisticated clientele. The cuisine has been acclaimed as Seattle's best by the media and more importantly, by local diners. Il Terrazzo Carmine is located in historic Pioneer Square - nestled in an urban-renewed alley with entrances through the vintage lobby on First Avenue or through the delightful courtyard in the back. Since 1984, Carmine Smeraldo's classic Italian restaurant has been where the locals have chosen to return over and over again. From the Carpaccio Di Bue and Spaghettini Dell 'Ortolano for lunch to the Suprema Di Pollo Farcita and Zuppa Di Pesce for dinner you will know you have gone to a place where excellence is a way of life. Arguably the best Italian restaurant in Seattle, Il Terrazzo serves classical Italian cuisine with an atmosphere you may want to call home and never leave

A photo of La Fontana Siciliana restaurant

10. La Fontana Siciliana

4.8

Exceptional(1696)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Belltown / Pike Place Market

Booked 13 times today

La Fontana Siciliana in Seattle's vibrant Belltown neighborhood is a haven for authentic Sicilian cuisine, offering "the best I've had outside of Sicily!" With Chef Antonio Torralba at the helm, each dish is a masterpiece crafted from premier local ingredients, ensuring freshness and flavor. The enchanting courtyard, complete with a bubbling fountain, sets the perfect backdrop for a memorable dining experience. Guests rave about the "amazing food and ambience" and laud the "outstanding service" that makes every visit feel special. Whether enjoying a romantic dinner or a celebration, La Fontana Siciliana is a culinary journey to the heart of Sicily.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

D
Debi
Kansas City / Kansas •1 review
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
We flew from Georgia to visit my daughter and to try the pasta flight at Messina! Sadly around 21 minutes before our dinner time they cancelled the pasta flight service for the evening. However the food was amazing!! Every single dish was EXCELLENT!!!! The wait staff was phenomenal and fun to talk to. 10/10 would recommend!!! I will say that the host was kinda rude and a little short with us when we were asking about the discontinued flight service. Not what you expect at the front of the restaurant greeting people and setting the tone. Everything after that canceled her out thankfully!!
More info
MessinaPrice: Expensive• Italian• Queen Anne
•
4
R
Rex
Washington, D.C. Area •5 reviews
5.0
Dined 6 days ago
Superb, as usual. The carrot sformato was an unusual find and quite delicious. The addition of olives to the blood orange and fennel salad hit just the right acid note, Mama’s meatballs were pure beef with a strong dash of anise seed, and the accompanying marinara had been simmering for ages to pick up that deep complexity of flavors and great balance between sweet and slightly acid.
More info
The Pink DoorPrice: Very Expensive• Italian• Belltown / Pike Place Market
•
4.8
M
michelleVIP
Seattle / Eastern Washington •20 reviews
5.0
Dined 6 days ago
Our favorite place over the years! We love how the restaurant is tucked into the main building and the secure parking garage below. The food is always perfect and the staff knows exactly what wine to pair. We love the bar since it’s cozy and the tables have a bench seat on one side. The bar is beautiful and perfectly lit. The dessert tray is the best - we love how they bring it over so you can see what each one is!
More info
Il Terrazzo CarminePrice: Expensive• Italian• Pioneer Square
•
4.8
J
Jennifer
New York City •4 reviews
5.0
Dined on Dec 25, 2024
Excellent food on the Christmas Eve dinner menu and our server was equally good. Will definitely plan to do this again!
More info
Grappa - SeattlePrice: Expensive• Mediterranean• Queen Anne
•
4.7
T
TyVIP
Greater Boston •5 reviews
5.0
Dined on Dec 24, 2024
The mushroom risotto was incredible! The staff was amazing and super friendly.
More info
San FermoPrice: Very Expensive• Italian• Ballard
•
4.8

Explore OpenTable

Bainbridge Island

Italian

Best Italian Restaurants in Bainbridge Island

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

40 restaurants available nearby

1. The Pink Door

2. San Fermo

3. Mondello Ristorante Italiano

4. Messina

5. Stoneburner

6. Artusi (21 and over)

7. Grappa - Seattle

8. Spinasse

9. Il Terrazzo Carmine

10. La Fontana Siciliana

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable