Best Contemporary Italian Restaurants in Rutherford

60 restaurants available nearby

1. Sergio's Missione

4.7

Exceptional(39)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary italian • Lodi

Sergio's offers a wonderful Italian restaurant in Lodi, New Jersey, serving superb tasting Italian cuisine in an eclectic atmosphere, offering impeccable service. He takes personal pride in the variety of dishes to select from, working with his chefs to create exciting and wonderfully tasting cuisine. He not only makes his menu interesting but continues to amaze us with inspired specials. Combining this with his unique decorating style, Sergio welcomes you to an unforgettable dining experience.

A photo of Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC restaurant

2. Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC

4.6

Exceptional(29463)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary italian • Theater District

Booked 316 times today

Carmine's on 44th Street in NYC's Theater District embodies the essence of Southern Italian cuisine, offering a dining experience akin to an Italian American wedding feast. Guests rave about the "abundant portions" and "authentic flavors," highlighting dishes like the "best chicken Parm ever" and "fantastic lasagna." Known for its family-style servings, Carmine's creates a convivial atmosphere where "every meal feels like a Sunday afternoon at Grandma's." Reviewers consistently praise the "amazing atmosphere" and "excellent service," making it a must-visit for both locals and tourists seeking a traditional yet exceptional Italian meal in the heart of Times Square.

A photo of Aunt Jake's Pasta Experience restaurant

3. Aunt Jake's Pasta Experience

4.9

Exceptional(756)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary italian • Upper East Side

Booked 40 times today

Aunt Jake's Pasta Experience on New York’s Upper East Side offers a truly authentic and interactive Italian dining adventure. Renowned for its hands-on pasta-making classes followed by a delectable 3-course meal, Aunt Jake's ensures every guest not only eats like an Italian but learns the art too. Patrons rave about the quality and ambiance, with glowing reviews like, "This was one of the best pasta making experiences I’ve had. & the food .. omg delicious" and "Anthony was amazing! Overall, we had such a great experience." Whether it's a fun date night, a family gathering, or a solo culinary escapade, Aunt Jake’s provides an exceptional blend of education, entertainment, and gastronomic delight, making every visit memorable.

4. Il Fiorista

4.5

Awesome(240)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary italian • NoMad

Booked 34 times today

Il Fiorista in NoMad, New York, is a Mediterranean culinary gem that truly stands out for its commitment to quality and authenticity. Nestled just a short walk from Madison Square Park, this restaurant excels in incorporating fresh, local, and seasonal produce into its dishes, much like traditional Mediterranean cuisine. Guests rave about their experiences, with one noting, "the food was absolutely delicious, every bite was so yummy and stunningly presented!" Another guest praised the restaurant's ambiance and service, saying, "the design evokes the calm beauty of the flowers that give its name, the service is impeccable and warm." At Il Fiorista, the attention to detail, from the botanical ingredients to the beautifully crafted dishes, ensures a Mediterranean dining experience that is both delightful and memorable.

A photo of Cecconi's at The Ned NoMad restaurant

5. Cecconi's at The Ned NoMad

4.5

Awesome(349)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary italian • NoMad

Booked 50 times today

Cecconi's at The Ned NoMad in the vibrant NoMad neighborhood of New York offers an exquisite taste of Mediterranean cuisine with an Italian flair. Patrons rave about the "delicious Italian plates," highlighting the "finest quality" ingredients and "impeccable service." The restaurant's ambiance, featuring hand-chipped mosaic floors and plush seating, perfectly complements its sophisticated yet inviting atmosphere. Reviewers consistently praise dishes like the "best fusilli pomodoro I have ever had" and the "fresh, locally caught fish," underscoring Cecconi's commitment to quality and authenticity. With its elegant setting and renowned Mediterranean offerings, Cecconi's remains a top choice for a memorable dining experience in Manhattan.

A photo of Carmine's - 91st Street - NYC restaurant

6. Carmine's - 91st Street - NYC

4.6

Exceptional(8421)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary italian • Upper West Side

Booked 156 times today

Carmine's on 91st Street in NYC’s Upper West Side is a beacon of Contemporary Italian cuisine, where every meal is a festive celebration akin to an Italian American wedding feast. Known for its generous family-style servings, Carmine's delights diners with meticulously crafted Southern Italian dishes. As one diner raves, "The food never disappoints. It's always a great experience." From the succulent Chicken Parmesan to the divine pasta with sauce, every dish is a testament to authentic Italian flavors, prepared with a contemporary twist. The ambiance is lively and welcoming, perfect for large groups or a family dinner, making every visit to Carmine's a memorable culinary journey.

A photo of Piccola Cucina Uptown restaurant

7. Piccola Cucina Uptown

4.8

Exceptional(2096)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary italian • Upper East Side

Booked 101 times today

Piccola Cucina Uptown, nestled in the vibrant Upper East Side of New York, offers a delightful escape to the heart of Sicily with its authentic cuisine. As praised by diners, it's a place where "the food was amazing" and where traditional Sicilian dishes like "pasta alla bottarga" and "branzino cooked in bread" shine. Chef Philip Guardione brings Sicilian flavors to life with creativity and flair, ensuring each dish is a testament to Sicilian culinary traditions. The atmosphere is consistently lauded as "cozy" and "welcoming," making every visit memorable. Whether it's the "homemade pistachio gelato" or the "freshly cooked lasagna," every bite at Piccola Cucina Uptown transports diners straight to Sicily, making it a must-visit for authentic Sicilian cuisine in New York City.

8. Sogno Toscano

4.8

Exceptional(106)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary italian • West Village

Booked 8 times today

Sogno Toscano in West Village, New York, offers a truly authentic Italian Wine Bar experience that transports you straight to Tuscany. Diners rave about the "immaculate food, wine, vibes, and service," with a special mention for the "Lambrusco and charcuterie board that make you think you’re in Italy." This gem is known for its extensive selection of imported wines that perfectly complement their gourmet offerings. As one happy guest put it, "the wine is top notch," underscoring the quality that Sogno Toscano prides itself on. Whether you're a local or just visiting, Sogno Toscano provides a perfect slice of Italy with its exceptional wine and food pairings, making every visit a memorable one.

A photo of Stella 34 Trattoria restaurant

9. Stella 34 Trattoria

4.4

Awesome(3478)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary italian • Midtown West

Booked 44 times today

Stella 34 Trattoria in Midtown West, NYC, marries modern Italian cuisine with breathtaking views of the Empire State Building, creating a dining experience that is as visually stimulating as it is gastronomically satisfying. Esteemed for its authenticity, the pizzeria at Stella 34 beckons with "consistently excellent" pizzas that are a testament to traditional Italian craftsmanship. One patron praised the pizza as "very good," highlighting its stand-out quality even in a city known for great pizza. With its spacious, airy ambiance on the 6th floor of Macy’s and an attentive staff that enhances the dining experience, Stella 34 ensures every meal is memorable. Whether it's a casual dinner or a special event, this restaurant’s combination of delicious pizzas, stunning views, and impeccable service makes it a must-visit destination in NYC.

10. Osteria Nonnino

4.5

Awesome(218)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary italian • West Village

Booked 30 times today

Nestled in the vibrant West Village of New York, Osteria Nonnino offers a stellar dining experience with its contemporary Italian cuisine that blends the culinary traditions of northern and southern Italy. Chef Tony Kavaja, along with his wife Vita Russo, crafts authentic Italian dishes that resonate with diners. The rave reviews highlight dishes like the "fabulous" Orecchiette Con Bufala and the table-side Cacio e Pepe, emphasizing freshness and authenticity. Guests are especially fond of the "delicious and perfectly prepared" entrees and desserts, like the tiramisu made fresh at your table, which one diner described as "life-changing!" The restaurant's cozy atmosphere and attentive service make it a neighborhood gem, where every meal feels like a special occasion. This blend of excellent food, immersive ambiance, and warm hospitality ensures Osteria Nonnino is not just a meal, but a memorable experience, making it a must-visit for lovers of refined Italian cuisine.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

C
CHRISTINE
New York City •2 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
Everyone from the hostess to the bussers were friendly and attentive. Thanks for making our friends birthday special!
More info
Carmine's - 91st Street - NYCPrice: Expensive• Italian• Upper West Side
•
4.6
N
Nicole
New York City •1 review
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
I recently had the pleasure of dining at Carmine's on 44th with a large party, and I must say, the service was exceptional from start to finish! The hostess made us feel welcome from the moment we arrived, and the attentive service continued throughout the evening. I spoke with the manager, who went above and beyond to accommodate our needs, ensuring we had everything we needed for a great experience. The food was delicious, and the atmosphere was perfect for our gathering. I highly recommend Carmine's on 44th for its fantastic food and outstanding service!
More info
Carmine's - 44th Street - NYCPrice: Moderate• Italian• Theater District
•
4.6
R
Robertvip
New York City •44 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
Love the natural light and there is space for strollers. Service is always good and it’s a frequent lunch spot to entertain or meet friends
More info
Stella 34 TrattoriaPrice: Moderate• Italian• Midtown West
•
4.4
C
Carla
New Jersey •1 review
5.0
Dined 4 days ago
After my trip to Italy last year, I’ve been on the hunt for a restaurant that could replicate the incredible flavors and dining experience I had while I was there. Nothing seemed to compare—until we discovered this absolute gem. From the moment we walked in, I knew it was going to be special. The ambiance was warm and inviting, and the staff made us feel like we were part of the family. As for the food—wow. Each dish was more flavorful than the last, with ingredients that tasted as fresh and authentic as anything I had in Italy. Every bite transported me right back to the charming trattorias I dined at during my trip. It was exactly what I’d been craving, and I can’t wait to come back!
More info
Sapori Ristorante - MontclairPrice: Moderate• Italian• Montclair
•
4.7
E
Elizabethvip
New York City •5 reviews
5.0
Dined 5 days ago
I've never had a bad meal here, always excellent! It's one of my favorites in Montclair. I can always count on them to serve the best, interesting flavor combinations. Don't change a thing!!!
More info
Walnut Street KitchenPrice: Expensive• Contemporary Italian• Montclair
•
4.5

Explore OpenTable

Rutherford

Contemporary italian

Best Contemporary Italian Restaurants in Rutherford

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Award-winning

Accessibility

60 restaurants available nearby

1. Sergio's Missione

2. Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC

3. Aunt Jake's Pasta Experience

4. Il Fiorista

5. Cecconi's at The Ned NoMad

6. Carmine's - 91st Street - NYC

7. Piccola Cucina Uptown

8. Sogno Toscano

9. Stella 34 Trattoria

10. Osteria Nonnino

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable