Best Contemporary American Restaurants in Plumsteadville

First time at Stella to celebrate my wife's birthday and we thought the place was one of the best in the area. Food was delicious and atmosphere was great. Highly recommend!

As always, Chef Rucker knows how to bring it! The food, service, ambience, music and vibe were all on point. The swordfish belly app, lobster toast, hash browns, crab claws, blue fun tuna, cabbage, scallops, swordfish Milanese, sea bass, ham and squid ink biscuits and chicken were unreal. This is our third visit, and the consistency and quality were outstanding. We’ve probably had every menu item and have been enjoying the changing drinks menu as well. The matcha cocktail is a favorite, can drink it like water! The new mezcal Negroni was delish!!! You have to get the desserts. I crave them constantly now. The granola cremeaux is in my dreams.

It was a very busy Friday between Christmas and New Year’s, and we were thankful for Open Table and having made reservations! The mild weather brought everyone out to Peddler’s Village and all shops were crowded. The next best part was they didn’t run out of the favorite foods so we could get the specials plus anything else. We always enjoy the food and atmosphere here.

My wife and I had a very nice experience as usual. We chose an early dinner time, so the dining room wasn't crowded when we arrived (it did fill up quickly). Our server was very attentive without being intrusive. She took our order promptly, and the food was delivered to the table in a very reasonable amount of time. We both chose filet dishes (my order included crab cakes),, and the meat was prepared as ordered. We also ordered dessert: My wife had the berry crumble and I the flourless chocolate cake. Both were excellent. In summary, everything was as good as we have come to expect from Caleb's. We recommend them highly.

The food is always excellent, with innovative twists. The service was great, the staff is always pleasant, and you're never rushed. Brunch today, but lunch, dinner, or just drinks, a trip to The Water Wheel is NEVER a disappointment!