Best Contemporary American Restaurants in Cromwell

I have been to Arethusa’s before and had an amazing experience. I took my two daughters last night and I was so happy to have shared the experience with them. They were extremely impressed with the service and the quality of the food. This is surely a 5 star place for me. ❤️

I came for a brunch. I was going to order crab cakes Benedict. I asked about the crab cakes and whether they are pure crab. The response was that they were almost half bread. I ordered the short ribbon hash and vegetables. The hash had very little short ribs, and other than potatoes, I saw almost no vegetables. I was very disappointed.

Great place for a business/team meal. The Team loved their dinners!

My wife and I enjoyed a mouth-watering prime rib dinner in a quiet setting, served with perfect attentiveness to our needs. Each dish arrived at the very moment we were ready for it. We couldnt have been happier with our anniversary experience.

Never been before thought we’d give it a try. Don’t think the reservation was really necessary but the dining area was very clean and welcoming. The server, Lisa, was a super sweet and attentive. Helped make recommendations and substitutions as requested. The food was great. Spinach salad was a nice taste of summer with berries and goat cheese. I had the steak which was cooked as requested. The veggies were were also tender crisp and not covered in oil or butter. Definitely recommend this spot. Lisa was a true delight as a server and we had a great time with her.