Best Contemporary American Restaurants in Saint Augustine Beach

I’d say the best restaurant in town! The food is creative, distinctive, varied and absolutely delicious. We started with the beignets which had favors and a sauce that simply melted in your mouth. Every dish was “the winner” but my veggie platter had me humming with every bite. The atmosphere is beyond charming and the staff could not have been more attentive. By far, my St. Augustine favorite!!

Everything was perfect—from the service, to the ambience, the cocktails, and the food. This was our first time trying their food, and I could not have been more pleased. It was fresh, quick, and delicious. Highly recommend. One of my new favorites in St. Augustine.

Excellent service and food tonight. Great atmosphere, every table taken, that's also how you know this is a great restaurant. Thank you so much to Damien our server for your kindness and professionalism. Best Restaurant we have eaten at in St. Augustine.

I recently celebrated my 70th birthday with my wife at the Old City House restaurant and we had an indubitably delicious dinner with our fantastic waitress serving us. She sat us at a lovely corner table for two next to a window. The ambience was cozy, warm, elegant, relaxing, romantic and simply superb! The service was absolutely fantastic and the food was amazing, delightful and scrumptious. We enjoyed a very nice bottle of Ken Wright Cellars Pinot Noir 2023 from Williamette Valley, Oregon before we ordered our dishes. According to my wife, her magnificent lamb dish was wonderful! I savored a lovely cup of she-crab bisque and the beef tenderloin, which was a very flavorful, juicy, moist, succulent and tender Filet Mignon served with Vegetables, Gratin Potatoes and Topped with Herb and Truffle Butter. Dessert was quite delectable! We had an amazing dining experience. I told our fantastic waitress," ¡No me gusta, me encanta!"

Christmas dinner, reservations must be made 2-3 months in advance, the waitress was super professional, gave a lot of advice and we did not regret our choice. I would like to say separately about the toilet room, the dinner cost $260, and the manager sent us somewhere on the street around the corner and we did not find it, we left a lot of money for dinner and the lavatory was not included ... strange rules, I will give you some advice, the restaurant is in the lobby of the hotel and you need to ask the front desk to open it for you or ask the waiter and they will help you... this is just one inconvenience ... next Christmas we will be smarter, but we will definitely come back, the food is worth it