Best Caribbean Restaurants in Long Key

Food was very good overall. The couscous was very bland. The lobster was good but a touch chewy. The surprise anniversary key lime pie dessert was a wonderful surprise - this was the ONLY acknowledgment of our 25th wedding anniversary we received at this ‘resort’. Our Server was very friendly and did a lovely job. Service was a bit slow but that wasn’t his fault. We were one of 3 couples in the dining area so it wasn’t because they were busy. The prices aren’t bad considering how expensive this area is. The curry on my husband’s dish was delicious.

Wonderful, wonderful experience. These items were magnificent, the boat ride, crew, Sunset Key, the staff and service, the beach front seating under swaying palm trees, the crystal blue sky and water, the mojito, Crab tostada, sweet and tender Maine Lobster roll and two 'best ever' sweet additions the Salted Caramel Creme Brulee and Key Lime pie. Everything was absolutely on point! However, the two desserts score gold stars as hands down the best we've ever had and best Key Lime Pie anywhere in Key West. This is a must do in Key West! You must have reservations. In the off season with cooler breezes don't let the dress code requests concern you. Don't think - plan it- do it.

Visiting Key West for a few days, and walked by this restaurant in the morning and made the decision to visit for dinner. We started by sharing the crab cake which was delicious and full of crab and not fillers. Even the sauce was amazing. Also shared a delicious caesar salad before moving on to the main course. My date had the snapper special and I had the swordfish. Both were amazing. Our server was very friendly, but could have been slightly more attentive, such as refreshing our prosecco when we ran low.

This is a perfect place for an excellent dinner and relaxing atmosphere! Shrimp Alfredo was the best we’ve had - love the sun dried tomato accent!! Wait staff was great. (Sorry, don’t remember her name, but she was great!)

Great meal and atmosphere. The fried snapper sandwich I had was incredible. Should be on the regular menu. 👍👍