Best American Restaurants in East Berlin

Table 1837 at the Mill Inn was welcoming from the moment we arrived. Out table was ready. Immediately greated by our server (Sue). She was educated about specials and menu. We got our drinks and ordered food right away. We did not feel rushed. The decor was very warm and welcoming. The food was was assembled with great thought. Came out hot! Notable dishes were short rib, salmon, crab/lobster bisque. Wine prices were a little excessive. Overall experience was exceptional.

Our first time here as my wife and I just moved into Gettysburg a few months ago. Several people recommended we try it and so glad we did. Beautiful dining room and Jenna, our server, was so friendly and took great care of us during a busy Saturday night. We had oysters, onion soup, filet mignon and stuffed pork chop. Dessert was the s’mores cake. Everything was well prepared and delicious. We are looking forward to our next visit as they serve lunch and Sunday brunch too.

The nachos were not what I am used to but all other good was delicious

Very quaint ambiance in a small town, food is superb in taste and presentation, service is as well. Can't wait to come back and try other menu items.

We were skipped over a few times to be seated even though we had used priority seating. We had to tell the host we had been waiting over 1/2 hour instead of the 10 minutes we were told when we checked in. Our server was the best.